Court Hearings May Be Managed Around Official Judicial Training, But Parties Must Be Notified First

Official judicial training may affect hearing schedules, but courts must manage calendars and notify parties in advance of any cancelled hearing. Court users should know that official judicial training may justify the cancellation or adjustment of hearings, but only if the court calendar is properly managed and parties are notified in advance. For litigants, lawyers, […]

When Your Lawyer Collects Money for You, Legal Fees Cannot Just Be Taken by Force

A lawyer may claim fees but cannot unilaterally keep client funds. The Court suspended counsel for withholding recovered money beyond the acknowledged fee. Clients who recover money through litigation have a right to demand that their lawyer account for and turn over the proceeds, even when the lawyer believes that additional attorneyโ€™s fees are still […]

When Accrued Foreign Payments Trigger Withholding Tax in the Philippines

Accrued foreign interest and royalty expenses may trigger withholding tax when deducted by an accrual-basis taxpayer, even before actual remittance abroad. Philippine companies using the accrual method of accounting cannot deduct interest, royalties, or similar payments owed to non-resident foreign corporations as business expenses and later deny withholding tax liability on the ground that the […]

Late Tax Returns Cannot Rescue a Lost Labor Case

A timber employer could not reopen a lost labor case through late tax returns and a supplemental reconsideration motion filed beyond strict NLRC deadlines. Employers cannot use late tax records and successive reconsideration motions to reopen a labor case after losing before the Labor Arbiter and the NLRC. Favila v. Pagdanan Timber Products teaches a […]

RMO No. 42-99: BIR Court Pleadings May Be Verified or Certified by the Deputy Commissioner When the Commissioner Is Absent

RMO No. 42-99 authorizes the Deputy Commissioner, Legal and Enforcement Group, to verify or certify BIR court pleadings when the Commissioner is absent. Businesses and tax litigants dealing with court cases involving the Bureau of Internal Revenue should take note that the authority to verify or certify BIR pleadings is not limited to the Commissioner […]

When a Tax Refund Statute Has a Ceiling, Later Tax Increases Do Not Raise the Refund

Mining tax refunds are capped by the refund statute itself; later fuel tax increases do not enlarge the refund absent clear legal authority. Taxpayers claiming statutory refunds cannot enlarge the refund by relying on later tax increases unless the refund law itself clearly says so. For mining and lumber companies that paid specific taxes on […]

Tax Assessments Cannot Be Built on Informants Alone

A taxpayer defeated BIR deficiency assessments because informant claims and disputed presumptions could not replace actual facts and competent evidence. A taxpayer may defeat a deficiency tax assessment when the assessment rests on unverified informant claims, disputed presumptions, and missing documentary proof rather than actual facts proven by competent evidence. For businesses facing large assessments […]

RMO No. 19-99: BIR Tax Examinations Resume for Cases Near Prescription Despite Suspension Order

RMO No. 19-99 allows BIR audits and reinvestigations near prescription to proceed despite the March 1, 1999 suspension of tax examinations. Taxpayers with pending or potential deficiency tax cases near the prescription deadline could still be examined by the BIR despite the general suspension of tax examinations effective March 1, 1999. RMO No. 19-99 expands […]

Unsigned BIR Waivers Cannot Extend the Deadline to Assess Taxes

A taxpayer-only waiver cannot extend the BIRโ€™s assessment deadline. The Supreme Court voided late tax assessments issued without a valid written agreement. A tax assessment issued after the legal deadline is void when the taxpayerโ€™s supposed waiver of prescription was not validly accepted in writing by the Commissioner of Internal Revenue. A taxpayerโ€™s signature alone […]