No 10-Year Tax Assessment Period Without Proof of Fraudulent Return

A tax accused remained free from civil liability because the CTA found no proven fraudulent return and the deficiency income tax assessments for 2009 and 2010 had prescribed. Taxpayers facing criminal tax charges may still defeat a related civil claim for unpaid taxes when the government cannot prove that the return was fraudulent or false […]

BIR Capital Gains Tax Assessments Can Be Cancelled When Issued After Prescription

The tax court cancelled a Php355.48M CGT assessment after finding the BIR assessed too late and failed to prove a deliberate false return. Taxpayers facing old BIR assessments should carefully check prescription before debating the tax computation itself. In a major capital gains tax assessment dispute, the Court of Tax Appeals cancelled a Php355.48 million […]

BIR Cannot Revive a Prescribed Capital Gains Tax Assessment Through Internal Case Handling Lapses

The tax court denied the BIR’s bid to revive a prescribed CGT assessment, holding that internal lawyer reassignment was not excusable negligence. Taxpayers facing old capital gains tax assessments gain an important procedural protection from this ruling: once the government’s right to assess has prescribed and the judgment cancelling the assessment has become final, the […]

When a BIR Waiver Fails, the Tax Assessment Can Die With It

A defective BIR waiver did not extend the three-year tax assessment period, making the deficiency assessment against FMF Development time-barred. Taxpayers can defeat a BIR assessment on prescription when the supposed waiver extending the assessment period is defective. A waiver of the statute of limitations is not a blank check for the government: it must […]

When the BIR Waits Too Long: Tax Assessments Can Expire Even After They Are Issued

A timely BIR assessment can still become uncollectible if collection is filed too late; ordinary reconsideration protests do not suspend prescription. A tax assessment does not give the BIR an unlimited time to collect. Even if the government validly issues an assessment before the deadline, the right to collect that assessed deficiency tax can still […]

When the BIR Waits Too Long: Tax Collection Can Prescribe Even After a Timely Assessment

A timely BIR assessment does not preserve collection forever. The Court barred collection because no granted reinvestigation suspended prescription. A tax assessment issued on time does not give the government unlimited time to collect. If the Bureau of Internal Revenue fails to collect within the separate statutory period, and the taxpayer merely asked for reconsideration […]

Unsigned BIR Waivers Cannot Extend the Deadline to Assess Taxes

A taxpayer-only waiver cannot extend the BIR’s assessment deadline. The Supreme Court voided late tax assessments issued without a valid written agreement. A tax assessment issued after the legal deadline is void when the taxpayer’s supposed waiver of prescription was not validly accepted in writing by the Commissioner of Internal Revenue. A taxpayer’s signature alone […]

Tax Protests Can Stop Prescription When They Ask the BIR to Reconsider or Reinvestigate

A taxpayer’s request for BIR reconsideration can interrupt prescription, and withholding taxes accrued and recorded as payable must be remitted. A taxpayer who asks the BIR to reconsider or reinvestigate an assessment may stop the government’s collection period from running, even if the request is framed as a protest. For companies facing deficiency tax assessments, […]