RMC No. 52-2020: Temporary Email Filing of Withdrawal of Protest or FDDA Appeal for Tax Amnesty Cases

RMC No. 52-2020 temporarily allowed taxpayers to e-mail withdrawals of assessment protests or FDDA appeals for tax amnesty during ECQ/GCQ. Taxpayers pursuing tax amnesty while their assessment protest or FDDA appeal remained pending were temporarily allowed, beginning May 27, 2020, to file the required withdrawal by e-mail instead of being forced to physically appear before […]

Substantial Justice in Tax Appeals: Technical Defects Should Not End Cases

Tax appeals should not be dismissed for curable defects when substantial justice requires a merits ruling in a major BIR assessment case. Substantial justice in tax appeals means that a multimillion-peso tax case should not be thrown out merely because a petition contains curable formal defects, especially where both sides have attempted to correct the […]

Tax Appeal Equity Rule: Late CTA Appeals May Still Be Heard

A late CTA tax appeal may proceed when BIR assessment instructions caused confusion and no final decision had resolved the taxpayer’s protest. The Tax Appeal Equity Rule protects taxpayers from losing their day in court when a late Court of Tax Appeals filing was caused by the tax authority’s own confusing assessment instructions and when […]

False Return Tax Assessment Rule: When BIR Gets 10 Years to Assess

False withholding tax returns can give the BIR 10 years to assess, even without proving fraud, if substantial underdeclaration is shown. The false return tax assessment rule means a taxpayer may lose the ordinary three-year protection against BIR assessments when its return substantially understates taxes due, even if the taxpayer argues there was no intent […]

Tax Assessment Inaction Rule: Taxpayer Appeal Options

Taxpayers may await a final BIR decision after 180-day inaction and still appeal a protested assessment within 30 days from receipt. The tax assessment inaction rule protects taxpayers from losing their right to contest a deficiency assessment merely because the Bureau of Internal Revenue failed to act within 180 days. For corporations, landowners, and businesses […]

When BIR Paperwork Saves a Taxpayer: Voluntary Assessment Protection Requires Strict Registry Compliance

The Supreme Court cancelled BIR deficiency assessments because the taxpayer was not disqualified from VAP without proper registry recording. A taxpayer who comes forward under a voluntary assessment program may still be protected from deficiency assessments and related civil or criminal consequences if the BIR failed to complete the exact disqualification steps required by its […]

Security Agencies Cannot Deduct Guard Salaries from Contractor’s Tax Gross Receipts

Security agencies cannot deduct guard salaries and statutory contributions from contractor’s tax gross receipts; late protests can make BIR assessments final. Security agencies must treat the full amounts they receive from clients as taxable gross receipts for contractor’s tax purposes, even when much of those collections are later used to pay guards’ salaries, SSS, Medicare, […]

Tax Evasion Cases Can Proceed Even Before the BIR Finalizes the Assessment

A BIR assessment protest does not stop criminal tax prosecution when the charge involves a fraudulent return or willful attempt to evade tax. A taxpayer cannot stop a criminal tax evasion case merely by protesting a BIR assessment or arguing that the exact tax deficiency has not yet been finally computed. When the government alleges […]