Acquitted Corporate Check Signatories Are Not Automatically Liable for Company Debt

Corporate check signatories acquitted in BP 22 cases are not automatically personally liable for company debts; creditors must sue the proper debtor. A corporate employee who signs a company check is not automatically required to personally pay the company debt when a bouncing-check case ends in acquittal. The Supreme Court clarified that, in prosecutions involving […]

Stopped Bank Drafts Do Not Defeat a Holder in Due Course

A holder in due course may collect on stopped bank drafts; the bank-drawer remains liable despite a separate indemnity deal with its customer. A party who receives a negotiable bank draft in good faith and for value is not left empty-handed merely because payment is later stopped. When a bank draft is dishonored after a […]

When Your Company Lawyer Drops the Ball, the Company May Still Pay

Corporations cannot avoid money judgments by blaming simple negligence of in-house counsel; written payment undertakings may bind the company in collection cases. Corporate clients cannot usually escape an unfavorable money judgment by blaming their own lawyer, especially when the lawyer is an in-house legal officer and the company failed to monitor the case. In business […]

Court Employees Can Be Disciplined for Refusing to Pay Just Debts

Court employees may be disciplined for willfully refusing to pay admitted just debts, but administrative cases do not replace civil collection suits. Public employment does not shield a government worker from discipline when private financial obligations are knowingly evaded. For court personnel, the willful refusal to pay a just debt is not merely a personal […]

Unpaid Debts Alone Do Not Prove Court Employee Misconduct Without Clear Evidence

A disputed private debt cannot support administrative discipline unless adjudicated or admitted as just; the Supreme Court dismissed the complaint against a court clerk. A private debt dispute does not automatically become an administrative case against a court employee. The ruling teaches a practical doctrine for complainants and public employees alike: before discipline may be […]

Acquittal Does Not Always Wipe Out Debt: Civil Liability Can Survive a Criminal Case

Acquittal in a criminal case does not automatically erase civil liability when the evidence proves an unpaid debt or obligation from the same transaction. A person acquitted in a criminal case may still be ordered to pay the private complainant when the same evidence shows that a debt or civil obligation remains unpaid. For victims […]

Winning a Money Judgment Does Not Always Mean Immediate Collection

A money judgment may not be collectible immediately on appeal; improper execution pending appeal can be stopped through certiorari. A party who wins a money judgment cannot always collect immediately while the case is still on appeal. Execution pending appeal is an extraordinary remedy, and when a trial court allows it without proper legal basis, […]

A Demand Letter Can Restart the Clock on Collection Claims

Written creditor demands can interrupt prescription and restart the limitation period, allowing collection suits that might otherwise appear time-barred. A creditor who sends a proper written demand before prescription sets in may get more than a brief pause in time: the prescriptive period begins anew from the debtor’s receipt of the demand. For banks, lenders, […]

A Dollar Payment Clause May Be Illegal, But the Debt Itself Can Still Be Collected in Pesos

A dollar-payment clause may be void, but a real debt can still be collected in pesos. Ponce clarifies recovery of foreign-currency-linked obligations. Creditors are not automatically left unpaid just because a loan arrangement involved payment in U.S. dollars. The controlling rule is practical and equitable: an illegal foreign-currency payment clause may be void, but the […]