When Insurance Contracts Point to Arbitration, Courts Must Send the Right Parties There

The Supreme Court enforced an incorporated arbitration clause and held that courts must refer bound parties to arbitration even in multi-party disputes. Businesses that accept insurance, membership, or commercial contracts incorporating separate rules may be bound by arbitration clauses found outside the signed main document. The Supreme Court made clear that when a valid arbitration […]

Notarized Surety Agreements Are Hard to Escape: Why a Forgery Defense Needs More Than a Handwriting Report

A notarized surety agreement cannot be defeated by denial alone; forgery must be proven by clear, convincing evidence, not weak handwriting comparison. Business owners, corporate officers, and loan sureties cannot lightly escape a notarized surety agreement by merely denying their signature or presenting an inconclusive handwriting report. When a person signs as surety for a […]

Mining Contract Disputes Must Go to Arbitration When Parties Agreed to Arbitrate

The Supreme Court dismissed parallel mining contract cases for forum shopping and enforced arbitration despite attempts to proceed in court. Businesses that agree to arbitrate cannot avoid that bargain by filing parallel cases before courts and administrative agencies, especially when both cases arise from the same contract, seek substantially the same relief, and risk conflicting […]

Family Corporations Cannot Combine Rehabilitation Cases Just Because They Share Owners

Family corporations cannot jointly file rehabilitation cases under old rules merely because they share owners; each debtor must satisfy venue and filing requirements. Family-owned corporations in financial distress cannot assume that shared stockholders, common officers, or intertwined business affairs will let them file one combined rehabilitation case. The ruling establishes a strict separate-corporate-personality rule for […]

Signed and Notarized Loan Documents Are Hard to Undo: When Courts Will Enforce Bank Mortgages Despite Claims of Fraud

Business borrowers challenging signed bank loan and mortgage documents must overcome presumptions of regularity with clear and convincing evidence. Borrowers, corporate officers, and property owners who sign notarized loan, mortgage, pledge, or surety documents cannot later defeat foreclosure by relying on bare allegations that the papers were simulated, coerced, or unsupported by consideration. The Supreme […]

A Final Judgment Cannot Be Delayed by an Unproven Set-Off Claim

Final judgments may be executed despite an alleged set-off claim unless the opposing debt is liquidated, demandable, admitted, or finally adjudicated. A party who has already won a final judgment is generally entitled to collect immediately, even if the losing party says it has a separate claim that might later reduce or offset what it […]

When Foreign Investors Become Philippine Litigation Targets: The Line Between Passive Investment and Doing Business

Foreign companies that actively direct Philippine operations may be sued locally, but courts still require strict service of summons before trial can proceed. Foreign companies that actively manage, negotiate, or direct Philippine operations may be treated as having transacted business here, even if they claim to be only investors. For companies facing tax, commercial, or […]

When a Company Name Does Not Shield a Trader Who Personally Received the Goods

A trader who personally received imported goods was held liable, while the corporation was absolved absent proof it authorized or assumed the obligation. A person who personally receives imported goods and undertakes to dispose of them cannot avoid liability merely by pointing to a company name, especially when the evidence shows that the person, not […]

When a Company Can Stop Another Business From Using a Confusingly Similar Name

The Supreme Court upheld SEC power to stop a later corporation from using a confusingly similar name, protecting prior corporate identity and compliance. A corporation that first lawfully adopts and uses a distinctive corporate name can compel a later corporation to drop a confusingly similar name, even without proving actual customer confusion, when the similarity […]

When a Corporate President Exceeds Authority, the Company May Not Be Bound

A corporate president’s unauthorized speculative contracts did not bind the company, and damages failed for lack of proof of actual loss. A company is not automatically liable for every contract signed or arranged by its president. When the transaction falls outside the president’s actual authority, contradicts board policy, and is never ratified by the corporation, […]