When Contract Breach Lets a Government Authority Take Back Its Property

A contract takeover clause may be enforced despite pending litigation when default is not seriously disputed and no clear right to injunction exists. Contracting parties who agree in advance that a lease or development contract may be rescinded upon default cannot always run to court to stop the takeover. Where the breach is not seriously […]

When Invoices Are Not Enough: What Businesses Must Prove Before Charging Agents for Missing Goods

Businesses must prove actual receipt, not just shipment records, before charging agents for missing goods. The Court reduced damages unsupported by delivery proof. Businesses that rely on agents, distributors, and field sales representatives cannot recover alleged shortages simply by pointing to internal invoices or shipment records. To hold an agent financially liable, the company must […]

When a Deal Is Not Yet a Deal: Why Draft Terms, Napkin Notes, and Unauthorized Negotiations May Not Bind a Corporation

A contract needs definite consent and corporate authority. Drafts, counteroffers, and unauthorized negotiations may not bind a company or justify damages. Business owners cannot assume that a commercial deal is enforceable simply because negotiations were serious, documents were drafted, or a representative appeared to agree. A contract is perfected only when there is a definite […]

A Merger Does Not Erase Old Receivables: Surviving Companies Can Still Collect Pre-Merger Debts

A merger transfers enforceable receivables to the surviving corporation, allowing it to collect pre-merger loans despite the original creditorโ€™s dissolution. Companies that survive a merger may still enforce loans, receivables, and contract rights that belonged to the absorbed company, even when the debt arose before the merger and even when the original creditorโ€™s name appears […]

When a Court May Freeze Assets Before Summons Is Served

Courts may issue attachment before summons, but property cannot be validly levied until jurisdiction over the defendant is acquired. A plaintiff may ask the court to issue a writ of preliminary attachment at the very start of a case, even before summons is served, but the defendantโ€™s property cannot be validly levied until the court […]

Foreign Companies Doing Business Without a Philippine License Cannot Sue in Philippine Courts

Unlicensed foreign corporations doing continuous business in the Philippines may be barred from suing locally, even when dealing with only one Philippine company. Unlicensed foreign corporations that make the Philippines a continuing base for sales, manufacturing, distribution, warranty support, or management participation may lose the right to sue in Philippine courts. A foreign company cannot […]

Businesses Wrongfully Hit by Attachment Can Claim Damages on the Bond Even After Appeal

A business wrongfully hit by preliminary attachment may still claim damages on the bond during appeal before judgment becomes final. A party whose property was wrongfully attached is not left without a remedy simply because the case has already moved on appeal. If the attachment is later declared illegal, damages against the attachment bond may […]

A Missed Court Notice Does Not Automatically Void Execution Pending Appeal

A defective three-day notice does not void execution pending appeal when the losing party later receives a real chance to oppose but fails to act. Parties who lose a money judgment cannot automatically undo execution pending appeal merely by pointing to a defect in the three-day notice of hearing, especially when they were later given […]