Tax Refund Claims Can Survive Prescription Challenges When the BIR Merely Rehashes Old Arguments

Taxpayers defending refund claims should preserve prescription arguments early; the court denied the Commissioner’s MR and sustained a CGT refund. Taxpayers who have already secured a tax refund victory should be ready to defend that ruling against post-decision challenges, but a reconsideration motion that simply repeats previously rejected prescription arguments will not, by itself, justify […]

Taxpayers Can Preserve Assessment Victories When Reconsideration Merely Rehashes Old Arguments

A taxpayer preserved its win after the tax court denied reconsideration of cancelled deficiency income tax, VAT, withholding tax, DST, and penalties. Taxpayers who secure the cancellation of a deficiency tax assessment should treat the government’s motion for reconsideration as another litigation stage, not as an automatic reopening of the case. Where the motion merely […]

Withdrawing a Tax Refund Case Can End the CTA Dispute, But Taxpayers Must Treat It as a Strategic Litigation Decision

Taxpayers may withdraw a CTA refund or tax credit case when litigation costs outweigh recovery, subject to court discretion after proceedings progress. Taxpayers pursuing refund or tax credit claims before the Court of Tax Appeals should carefully assess litigation costs, business priorities, and evidentiary readiness before continuing trial, because a voluntary withdrawal may be allowed […]

Underdeclaration Alone Does Not Save a Prescribed BIR Assessment

A 30% underdeclaration is only prima facie evidence of fraud; without proof of fraud, the BIR cannot rely on the 10-year assessment period. Taxpayers facing old BIR assessments should carefully examine prescription because a 30% underdeclaration, by itself, does not automatically give the Commissioner ten years to assess. In this ruling, the Court of Tax […]

Tax Assessments Can Be Voided When the BIR Fails to Explain Its Decision in Writing

Taxpayers may challenge BIR assessments when the Commissioner denies a protest without explaining in writing why the taxpayer’s arguments were rejected. Taxpayers who file a protest against a BIR assessment must receive more than a bare rejection of their position. Where the Commissioner fails to explain in writing why the taxpayer’s factual and legal arguments […]

RMO No. 47-2025: New BIR Commissioner Assumes Duty and Updates Signing Authority for Tax Documents

RMO No. 47-2025 confirms CHARLITO MARTIN R. MENDOZA’s assumption as BIR Commissioner effective November 13, 2025 and updates official signing references. Businesses, withholding agents, accountants, and tax practitioners should immediately recognize CHARLITO MARTIN R. MENDOZA as the Commissioner of Internal Revenue for purposes of official BIR documents, correspondence, issuances, and signature-dependent transactions. RMO No. 47-2025 […]

Tax Assessment Settlement Ends Court Dispute After Withdrawal of Petition for Review

A taxpayer’s BIR assessment case was closed after a compromise settlement, but only after the court granted withdrawal of the pending petition for review. Taxpayers who settle an assessment case while it is pending before the Court of Tax Appeals should not assume that payment or compromise alone automatically ends the litigation. A pending petition […]

Late Petition for Relief Leaves Tax Refund Judgment Final Against the BIR

A late petition for relief failed after the CTA enforced Rule 38’s strict double-period rule, leaving the taxpayer’s refund judgment final. Tax refund and tax credit cases do not remain open indefinitely just because one party later claims internal oversight, missed notice, or meritorious defenses. Once a Court of Tax Appeals judgment becomes final, a […]

Generic Objections Will Not Undo a Tax Refund Win in the Court of Tax Appeals

A refund taxpayer kept its partial CTA win after the Commissioner raised only general objections and failed to identify specific documentary defects. Taxpayers defending a favorable tax refund or tax credit ruling should be prepared to meet a motion for reconsideration, but the government cannot overturn a refund award through broad objections alone. Where the […]

RMO No. 51-2022: Immediate Signature and Document Preparation Rules for BIR Correspondence Under Commissioner Romeo D. Lumagui, Jr.

RMO No. 51-2022 confirms Commissioner Romeo D. Lumagui, Jr.’s assumption to duty and immediate signature rules for BIR documents. All BIR documents and official correspondences requiring the signature of the Commissioner of Internal Revenue had to be prepared under the name and authority of Commissioner Romeo D. Lumagui, Jr. effective November 15, 2022. For taxpayers, […]