A late petition for relief failed after the CTA enforced Rule 38’s strict double-period rule, leaving the taxpayer’s refund judgment final.

Tax refund and tax credit cases do not remain open indefinitely just because one party later claims internal oversight, missed notice, or meritorious defenses. Once a Court of Tax Appeals judgment becomes final, a petition for relief from judgment must strictly satisfy both reglementary periods under Rule 38; otherwise, the final judgment stands, even if the Commissioner seeks to reopen the case.

Background of the Tax Refund Dispute

The dispute arose from a taxpayer’s claim for refund or issuance of a tax credit certificate against the Commissioner of Internal Revenue. The Court had earlier issued a Decision dated 03 May 2024, and both parties later filed motions for partial reconsideration. Those motions were denied in a Resolution dated 15 November 2024, which the Commissioner received on 18 December 2024.

After no appeal was taken to the Court of Tax Appeals En Banc or to the Supreme Court within the prescribed period, the Court considered the 03 May 2024 Decision final and executory. The Decision was entered on 02 January 2025. The Commissioner later attempted to undo the effects of that finality by filing a petition for relief from judgment on 06 August 2025 (CTA Case No. 10501).

The Commissioner’s Attempt to Reopen the Final Judgment

The Commissioner argued that there were valid reasons for the failure to file a petition for review before the Court En Banc. The explanation focused on an incumbent legal assistant who allegedly failed to notify counsel of the 15 November 2024 Resolution denying the parties’ motions for partial reconsideration. The Commissioner also insisted that there were meritorious defenses against the taxpayer’s refund claim.

The taxpayer opposed the petition. It argued that the petition was already time-barred, that the alleged failure to appeal was not the kind of mistake or excusable negligence that would justify relief from judgment, and that the Commissioner was merely repeating arguments already raised in the answer, memorandum, and motion for partial reconsideration.

The Court Applied the Strict Double-Period Rule

The Court focused on Section 3, Rule 38 of the Rules of Court. A petition for relief from judgment is not an ordinary remedy. It is an equitable remedy allowed only in exceptional circumstances. To be available, it must be filed within two separate periods: first, within sixty days from the time the petitioner learns of the judgment, final order, or proceeding to be set aside; and second, not more than six months after the judgment or final order was entered.

The Court emphasized that these periods are jurisdictional and must be strictly complied with. It cited Supreme Court doctrine holding that non-compliance with the double-period requirement warrants outright dismissal. This strictness is tied to the public policy of immutability of final judgments: litigation must end, and final decisions cannot be reopened by invoking belated equitable relief outside the periods fixed by law.

Why the Commissioner’s Petition Was Too Late

The Commissioner tried to count the sixty-day period from 04 June 2025, when the Commissioner allegedly received the Court’s 28 May 2025 Resolution calling for the issuance of an entry of judgment. The Court rejected that reckoning. The 28 May 2025 Resolution was not the judgment or final order contemplated under Rule 38 for purposes of a petition for relief from judgment.

Instead, the relevant notice for the first period was the Commissioner’s receipt on 18 December 2024 of the 15 November 2024 Resolution denying the motions for partial reconsideration. Counting sixty days from that date, the Commissioner had only until 16 February 2025 to file a petition for relief from judgment.

The Commissioner also attempted to count the six-month period from 14 July 2025, when notice of the issuance of the entry of judgment was supposedly received. The Court again rejected that theory. The six-month period is reckoned from the actual entry of the decision, not from later notice that the entry had been issued. Since the 03 May 2024 Decision was entered on 02 January 2025, the six-month period expired on 02 July 2025.

Because the Commissioner filed the petition only on 06 August 2025, the Court found that both periods had already lapsed. The petition was therefore dismissed outright for being filed out of time.

Practical Meaning for Taxpayers and the BIR

For taxpayers with favorable refund or tax credit judgments, the ruling reinforces a key litigation protection: once the judgment becomes final and the entry date has passed, the opposing party cannot casually reopen the case by pointing to office lapses or by rearguing the merits. The strict double-period rule protects finality, certainty, and enforceability.

For taxpayers still litigating before the Court of Tax Appeals, the ruling is also a reminder to track every post-decision deadline. Motions for reconsideration, appeals to the Court En Banc, petitions for review, entries of judgment, and extraordinary remedies each have distinct legal effects. Confusing notice of an entry of judgment with the actual date of entry can be fatal.

For the Commissioner and government litigants, the ruling shows that institutional or personnel-related lapses will not automatically excuse a missed appeal. A petition for relief from judgment is not a substitute for a lost appeal, nor is it a vehicle for a second motion for reconsideration disguised as an equitable remedy.

Key Takeaway for Tax Refund and Tax Credit Cases

The most important takeaway is procedural: finality matters. In tax refund and tax credit litigation, a favorable ruling must still be monitored until the appeal periods close, the entry of judgment is issued, and enforcement or implementation steps are taken. At the same time, a party seeking to disturb a final judgment must strictly comply with Rule 38’s two deadlines. Missing either period may be enough to defeat the petition.

This ruling is particularly relevant to companies pursuing VAT refunds, income tax refunds, excise tax refunds, customs-related tax credits, and other tax credit certificate claims. The merits of a refund case are important, but procedural finality can determine whether the taxpayer can actually preserve and enforce the benefit of a favorable decision.

How Ablola, Saribong & Gueco Can Assist

Ablola, Saribong & Gueco assists taxpayers, importers, corporate finance teams, and business owners in Court of Tax Appeals litigation, including tax refund claims, deficiency tax assessments, customs disputes, motions for reconsideration, appeals, and post-judgment enforcement strategy. Our tax litigation practice helps clients identify critical deadlines, preserve remedies, oppose defective or late filings, and convert favorable tax rulings into practical results.

If your company is pursuing a tax refund, defending against a BIR assessment, or dealing with a final or near-final CTA ruling, visit MakatiLawFirm.com to consult with our tax litigation team.


Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *