When a Strike Ends, Who Must Take Workers Back? The Supreme Court Draws the Line on Backwages and Successor Liability

Supreme Court limits backwage liability after a strike while allowing re-admission remedies and specific wage claims against the proper parties. Workers who are unfairly refused re-admission after a strike may recover backwages, but the Supreme Court made one critical limitation clear: liability does not automatically follow every company that later takes over operations, especially where […]

Ignoring a Court Order Is Not Cured by Partial Payment or Good Intentions

Partial compliance and good faith did not purge contempt where a lawyer failed to fully obey a court order to account for disputed labor-case proceeds. A party held in contempt cannot escape punishment by making partial payment, offering explanations, or invoking good faith after failing to fully obey a clear court directive. The practical lesson […]

Probationary Employees Can Still Be Let Go When There Is No Fixed Tenure or Anti-Union Proof

Trial employment may end without illegal dismissal when no fixed tenure exists and anti-union motive is not proven by substantial evidence. Employers may validly end a probationary or trial employment arrangement when the worker has no fixed tenure and the dismissal is not proven to be anti-union, even if the employee later claims that the […]

When a Union Certification Fight Becomes Moot: Why Courts Will Not Decide Bargaining Rights for Vessels No Longer Operated

A union certification challenge was dismissed as moot after the employer stopped operating the vessels involved and the union showed no active interest. A union certification dispute can disappear before the court reaches the merits when the employer no longer operates the workplace or vessels involved, the union shows no continuing interest, and no present […]

When Equal Pay Becomes a Legal Duty: What Employers Must Know About Wage Inequities and Collective Bargaining

PNR confirms that wage inequities may justify salary adjustments when comparable employees are treated unevenly and management fails to bargain in good faith. Employers cannot defeat wage-standardization claims simply by saying the company has limited funds, especially when the record shows that similarly situated employees in other departments received better treatment. Where employees performing comparable […]

A Closed Business May Still Owe Back Wages When Its Own Records Show Continued Operations

Employers cannot cut off back wage liability by merely claiming closure when records show continued operations or a connected successor enterprise. Employers cannot defeat a back wage award simply by declaring that the business had already closed if the record shows continued operations, asset transfers, or a successor arrangement pointing to the same enterprise. Community […]

Foreign Companies Recruiting Filipinos Cannot Hide Behind an Offshore Address

Foreign companies recruiting Filipinos through local representatives may be treated as doing business and sued in Philippine courts for labor claims. Foreign companies that use the Philippines as a place to recruit Filipino workers, maintain a local representative, or carry out recurring business-related acts may be treated as doing business hereβ€”and may be sued here […]

When Non-Union Employees Cannot Be Charged Union Lawyer’s Fees

Non-union supervisors who received employer-extended wage increases could not be charged union lawyer’s fees without representation, consent, or CBA coverage. Employees who receive wage increases because their employer voluntarily extends benefits across the company cannot automatically be made to pay the union lawyer who negotiated those benefits for another group. The doctrine is simple but […]

When Cross-Examination Is Denied, Labor Evidence Can Collapse

Untested testimony cannot support dismissal in labor cases; employers must prove suspension grounds or face reinstatement and limited back wages. A party in a labor case cannot be made to lose property, employment rights, or back wages on the strength of testimony it never had a fair chance to test. The Cross-Examination Completion Doctrine means […]

When One Judge Is Not Enough: Why Reconsideration Must Be Decided by the Proper Tribunal

A single judge cannot deny reconsideration when the law requires en banc action. The ruling warns taxpayers and businesses to verify proper tribunal authority. A motion for reconsideration is not a mere formality when the law requires a collegial body to act. If a court or administrative tribunal must decide en banc, a ruling issued […]