When a Labor Case Becomes Moot, Courts Will Not Decide It Just to Settle the Argument

A labor prohibition case was dismissed as moot after the parties no longer needed a ruling on the certification election dispute. A party asking a court to stop an ongoing labor proceeding may lose the case without any ruling on the merits if later events make the dispute academic. The practical lesson is simple but […]

Back Wages Require Proof of Actual Layoff, Not Equal Treatment Alone

Back wages require proof of actual layoff or lost work; employees cannot rely only on co-workers’ reinstatement when their facts are materially different. Employees who are excluded from a reinstatement award cannot obtain back wages merely by pointing to co-workers who received relief; they must show that their own separation, layoff, or exclusion from work […]

When Losing in Court Is Not Enough to Discipline a Judge

Adverse rulings do not prove judicial misconduct. PAFLU v. Tabigne requires clear evidence before a judge may be disciplined for alleged bias or delay. A party who believes a judge acted unfairly cannot secure judicial discipline merely by pointing to adverse orders, delay, or dissatisfaction with how a case was handled. The complainant must prove […]