Customs Smuggling Charges Fail When Prosecutors Cannot Prove Importation

The tax court acquitted an importer in a customs smuggling case after prosecutors failed to prove that the alleged cigarette shipment was actually imported. Importers and customs brokers facing criminal smuggling charges should closely examine whether the prosecution can prove the first and most basic fact: that the goods were actually imported into the Philippines. […]

Tax Evasion Charges Can Fail Before Trial When the Information Is Defective

A criminal tax case was dismissed after prosecutors failed to correct defects in the Information, highlighting key defenses in tax evasion prosecutions. Prosecutors pursuing criminal tax cases must ensure that the Information is complete, accurate, and supported by required attachments, because unresolved pleading defects may result in dismissal before the accused is ever required to […]

Late Criminal Tax Cases Can Be Dismissed When the Five-Year Prescription Period Has Already Run

A criminal tax case was dismissed after the Court found the five-year prescription period had run before the Information was filed. Taxpayers facing criminal tax charges may invoke prescription where the government files the Information in the Court of Tax Appeals beyond the five-year period under the Tax Code, especially when the alleged failure to […]

Criminal Tax Cases Can Be Dismissed When the Government Files the Information Too Late

A criminal tax case was dismissed after the Information was filed beyond the five-year prescription period for alleged failure to file an income tax return. Taxpayers and corporate officers facing criminal tax charges may still invoke prescription when the government takes too long to elevate a tax offense from preliminary investigation to the Court of […]

Customs Criminal Cases Can Be Dismissed When Probable Cause Evidence Is Incomplete

Customs fraud information dismissed without prejudice after the prosecution failed to submit annexes needed to establish probable cause before the Court of Tax Appeals. Importers and business owners facing customs fraud charges should know that a criminal case cannot proceed on allegations alone: before an arrest warrant may issue, the Court of Tax Appeals must […]

Tax Criminal Cases Can Survive Prescription but Still Fall to Prosecutorial Delay

A criminal tax case survived prescription because the DOJ complaint tolled the period, but was still dismissed due to over 10 years of unjustified delay. Taxpayers facing criminal tax charges may still secure dismissal even when the government beats the five-year prescriptive period, if prosecutors allow the case to linger for years without adequate justification. […]

Tax Evasion Charges Can Be Dismissed When the Accused Was Never Properly Notified

Tax crime case for alleged VAT non-payment dismissed without prejudice after defective subpoena service denied the accused due process in preliminary investigation. Businesses and corporate officers facing criminal tax charges must be given a genuine opportunity to participate in the preliminary investigation before they are brought to trial. In this Resolution, the Court of Tax […]

Tax Evasion Case Dismissed After Government Filed Criminal Information Too Late

Criminal tax prosecution dismissed after the government filed the Information beyond the five-year prescriptive period under the Tax Code. Taxpayers facing criminal tax charges should closely examine prescription before entering into the merits of the accusation, because even serious allegations under the Tax Code cannot proceed when the government files the criminal Information beyond the […]

Late Reconsideration Cannot Revive a Prescribed Criminal Tax Case

Criminal tax charges were dismissed after the court found prescription and denied a late prosecution reconsideration motion filed beyond the five-day period. Taxpayers and responsible corporate officers facing criminal tax charges should pay close attention to prescription and procedural deadlines, because even the government may lose its right to prosecute when the Information is filed […]

Late Reconsideration Can End a Criminal Tax Case Before the Merits Are Reached

A criminal tax prosecution stayed dismissed after the Court rejected a late reconsideration motion filed beyond the five-calendar-day deadline. Prosecutors in criminal tax cases must observe the five-calendar-day deadline for seeking reconsideration of a meritorious motion ruling, because a late motion may be denied outright even when the government also asks to amend the Information. […]