A criminal tax case was dismissed after the Information was filed beyond the five-year prescription period for alleged failure to file an income tax return.
Taxpayers and corporate officers facing criminal tax charges may still invoke prescription when the government takes too long to elevate a tax offense from preliminary investigation to the Court of Tax Appeals. In this ruling, the criminal case for failure to file an income tax return was dismissed because the prosecution filed the Information years after the five-year period recognized by the court had already expired.
Background of the Criminal Tax Case
The dispute arose from a criminal charge against a domestic hauling corporation, its manager, and its treasurer for alleged failure to make and file the corporationâs income tax return for taxable year 2012. The Information alleged that the return should have been filed on or before April 15, 2013, and that the failure resulted in unpaid income tax of P1,010,856.58, excluding interest and penalties.
The charge was based on Section 255 of the 1997 National Internal Revenue Code, in relation to Sections 253(d) and 256, which penalize certain failures to file returns, supply correct information, pay tax, withhold and remit tax, or refund excess taxes withheld, and which also address liability of responsible corporate officers in appropriate cases. The Information was filed before the Court of Tax Appeals only on May 27, 2024, and the case was later dismissed by the Court in Division for lack of jurisdiction and/or prescription. The government then elevated the matter to the Court of Tax Appeals En Banc (CTA EB Crim. No. 164).
The Key Issue: When Does Prescription Run in a Criminal Tax Case?
The central issue was whether the governmentâs right to prosecute the alleged criminal tax offense had already prescribed. Under Section 281 of the Tax Code, violations of any provision of the Code prescribe after five years. The provision also states that prescription begins to run from the day of the commission of the violation, or, if the violation was not known at the time, from discovery and the institution of judicial proceedings for investigation and punishment. Prescription is interrupted when proceedings are instituted against the guilty persons and begins to run again if the proceedings are dismissed for reasons not constituting jeopardy.
The government argued that the filing of the criminal complaint for preliminary investigation with the Department of Justice should interrupt the running of the five-year prescriptive period. It relied on later jurisprudence recognizing that a complaint filed before the prosecution office may toll prescription. The accused countered that, under the controlling rule applied to the case, the relevant period should be measured up to the filing of the Information in court, and that the 2024 filing came too late.
The Court Affirmed the Dismissal for Prescription
The Court of Tax Appeals En Banc denied the governmentâs petition and affirmed the dismissal of the criminal case. It applied the rule from Lim, which interpreted the predecessor provision of the Tax Code and held that, in tax offenses where the violation is discovered and proceedings for investigation are instituted, the government must still file the Information in court within five years from the institution of the proceedings for investigation and punishment.
On the facts, the Bureau of Internal Revenue referred the Joint Complaint-Affidavit to the Department of Justice for preliminary investigation on June 29, 2016. The court treated that date as the start of the five-year period. Counting five years from June 29, 2016, the prosecution had until June 29, 2021 to file the Information with the Court of Tax Appeals. Because the Information was filed only on May 27, 2024, the court held that the criminal action was belated and properly dismissed on the ground of prescription.
Why the Later Supreme Court Rule Did Not Save the Prosecution
A significant part of the ruling concerned the Supreme Courtâs later pronouncement in People v. Consebido, which adopted a unified rule that the filing of the complaint before the prosecution office tolls the running of the prescriptive period. If that rule were applied to the prosecutionâs position without limitation, it could have supported the argument that the filing before the Department of Justice interrupted prescription.
However, the Court of Tax Appeals En Banc held that the Consebido doctrine applies prospectively. Because the criminal tax case had already been affected by the prior rule and because criminal prescription is generally construed in the manner most favorable to the accused, the court did not apply the new doctrine retroactively to revive the prosecution. The result was that the old framework controlled, and the prosecutionâs late filing of the Information remained fatal.
The Dissent: A Different View on Retroactivity
The decision also included a dissenting opinion. The dissent took the view that Consebido should apply retroactively to pending tax cases because it concerns a procedural rule on the interruption of prescription, not a change in the elements or penalties of a criminal offense. Under that view, the filing of the complaint with the Department of Justice on June 29, 2016 both marked discovery of the offense and interrupted the running of prescription, meaning the governmentâs case should not have been dismissed as time-barred.
The majority, however, prevailed. For taxpayers and corporate officers, the controlling outcome is that the dismissal stood. The Court of Tax Appeals En Banc affirmed that the government could no longer proceed with the criminal tax case because the Information was filed beyond the applicable five-year period.
Practical Takeaways for Taxpayers and Corporate Officers
This ruling is important for corporations, directors, treasurers, managers, and other responsible officers who receive subpoenas, preliminary investigation notices, or Informations involving alleged Tax Code violations. Prescription is not merely a technical defense. In criminal tax litigation, it can determine whether the government may still prosecute at all.
Taxpayers should carefully reconstruct the timeline of the alleged offense, the date of discovery by the tax authorities, the filing of the complaint with the Department of Justice, and the eventual filing of the Information with the Court of Tax Appeals. A delay of several years between preliminary investigation and court filing may create a viable prescription defense, especially where the governing rule applicable to the case requires the Information to be filed within five years.
The ruling also shows why corporate officers should not assume that a criminal tax case is automatically valid simply because an Information has been filed. The Court of Tax Appeals may examine prescription at the outset based on the Information and supporting documents. If the timeline shows that the governmentâs right to prosecute has expired, dismissal may be warranted before trial.
For businesses, the decision is also a reminder to maintain complete tax records, board documents, officer appointment records, return filing confirmations, and communications with accountants or tax agents. In criminal tax cases, the defense often turns not only on whether the tax return was filed or the tax was paid, but also on who was responsible, when the government discovered the alleged violation, and whether the prosecution moved within the legally allowed period.
How Ablola, Saribong & Gueco Can Help
Ablola, Saribong & Gueco assists taxpayers, corporate officers, importers, and business owners in tax assessments, criminal tax investigations, Department of Justice preliminary investigations, and cases before the Court of Tax Appeals. Our tax litigation practice can review the prosecution timeline, evaluate prescription and jurisdictional defenses, prepare counter-affidavits, and represent clients in both civil and criminal tax proceedings.
If your company or officers have received a subpoena, tax fraud referral, criminal complaint, or Information involving alleged violations of the Tax Code, early legal review is critical. Visit MakatiLawFirm.com to consult our tax litigation team and assess your available remedies before deadlines and procedural risks narrow your options.