Tax Refund Proof Rule: Why Missing Returns Can Defeat Refund Claims

Corporate tax refunds require strict proof that excess credits were not carried over or used; missing returns can defeat refund claims. Corporate taxpayers claiming a refund of excess creditable withholding taxes must prove not only that taxes were withheld, but also that the same amounts were not already carried over, credited, or otherwise used against […]

When a Philippine Branch Acts Like a Broker, Internal Commissions Can Still Be Taxed

Foreign branches may owe percentage tax when local activities function as brokerage services, even if payments are routed as head-office allocations. A foreign corporation cannot avoid Philippine percentage tax simply by describing its Philippine branch’s income as an internal head-office allocation when the branch is, in substance, brokering import-export transactions in the Philippines. If the […]

When Retained Earnings Become Taxable: The Business-Need Rule for Philippine Corporations

Cyanamid clarifies that retained earnings must be proven necessary for business needs, or corporations may face improperly accumulated earnings tax after a BIR assessment. Corporations that keep profits instead of declaring dividends cannot rely on broad claims of “working capital” to avoid the improperly accumulated earnings tax. The controlling lesson of Cyanamid Philippines is practical […]

When Retained Earnings Become Taxable: The Cyanamid Rule on Improperly Accumulated Profits

Cyanamid confirms that retained earnings may be taxed when a corporation cannot prove they are needed for immediate, reasonable business purposes. Corporations that keep profits inside the company instead of declaring dividends may be taxed if they cannot prove that the retained earnings are needed for the immediate and reasonable needs of the business. The […]

When a Tax Refund Statute Has a Ceiling, Later Tax Increases Do Not Raise the Refund

Mining tax refunds are capped by the refund statute itself; later fuel tax increases do not enlarge the refund absent clear legal authority. Taxpayers claiming statutory refunds cannot enlarge the refund by relying on later tax increases unless the refund law itself clearly says so. For mining and lumber companies that paid specific taxes on […]

Tax Assessments Cannot Be Built on Informants Alone

A taxpayer defeated BIR deficiency assessments because informant claims and disputed presumptions could not replace actual facts and competent evidence. A taxpayer may defeat a deficiency tax assessment when the assessment rests on unverified informant claims, disputed presumptions, and missing documentary proof rather than actual facts proven by competent evidence. For businesses facing large assessments […]

Unsigned BIR Waivers Cannot Extend the Deadline to Assess Taxes

A taxpayer-only waiver cannot extend the BIR’s assessment deadline. The Supreme Court voided late tax assessments issued without a valid written agreement. A tax assessment issued after the legal deadline is void when the taxpayer’s supposed waiver of prescription was not validly accepted in writing by the Commissioner of Internal Revenue. A taxpayer’s signature alone […]

When a Taxpayer Chooses Tax Credit, the Refund Door Closes

A taxpayer that carries over excess income tax as credit cannot later claim a refund; tax remedies are alternative and statutory deadlines control. A corporation that carries over excess quarterly income tax payments as a tax credit cannot later change course and demand a cash refund for the same amount. Once the taxpayer makes that […]