Stock Dividends With Par Value Are Taxed on Par Value, Not Book Value

Stock dividends with par value are subject to documentary stamp tax based on par value, not book value, limiting BIR deficiency assessments. Corporations issuing stock dividends with par value cannot be assessed documentary stamp tax based on the higher book value of those shares when the stock certificates themselves state a par value. For companies […]

University Research Grants Are Not Automatically Taxable Service Income

Research grants to a non-profit university unit are not automatically taxable contractor income without proof of a commercial service business. Non-profit schools and their research units do not become taxable contractors merely because they receive sponsored research funding. Before the government can impose contractorโ€™s tax, it must first prove a taxable business transaction: that the […]

Actual Market Value Mineral Tax: How Mining Taxes Are Computed

Philippine mineral ad valorem tax is based on extraction value, not refined export price; surcharge fails when delay is justified by facts. The Actual Market Value Mineral Tax Rule tells mining companies that mineral taxes are not computed on a later, refined, or manufactured export product when the taxable mineral already had an ascertainable value […]

Tax Amnesty Can Cancel Even Previously Assessed Deficiency Taxes

A valid tax amnesty can cancel even prior deficiency assessments when the law does not expressly exclude them, and BIR rules cannot add new exceptions. Taxpayers who validly avail of a tax amnesty may be relieved even from deficiency tax assessments already issued before the amnesty law, unless the amnesty measure itself expressly excludes those […]

Tax Protests Can Stop Prescription When They Ask the BIR to Reconsider or Reinvestigate

A taxpayerโ€™s request for BIR reconsideration can interrupt prescription, and withholding taxes accrued and recorded as payable must be remitted. A taxpayer who asks the BIR to reconsider or reinvestigate an assessment may stop the governmentโ€™s collection period from running, even if the request is framed as a protest. For companies facing deficiency tax assessments, […]

A Tax Mistake Is Not Tax Fraud: When the BIR Cannot Impose the 50% Fraud Surcharge

A disclosed tax error is not fraud. The Supreme Court deleted the 50% surcharge because the taxpayer revealed the disputed remittance in his return. Taxpayers who disclose a questionable receipt in their income tax return are not automatically tax fraudsters, even if the amount is later found taxable. Fraud requires actual, intentional deception; an error, […]

Foreign Airlines Can Be Taxed on Philippine Ticket Sales Even Without Local Flights

Foreign airlines may be taxed on Philippine ticket sales even without local flights when local offices generate revenue through reservations and ticketing. A foreign airline may owe Philippine income tax even when none of its aircraft actually fly out of the country, if its Philippine office or agent sells tickets and performs commercial activities here. […]

When a Tax Veto Does Not Mean a Tax Refund

A hotel could not recover catererโ€™s tax payments because the three percent gross receipts tax remained valid despite a veto dispute. Hotels and restaurants cannot avoid a duly imposed gross receipts tax merely by pointing to a veto controversy, when the taxing provision that applies to them remained in force through the tax laws in […]

When the BIR Keeps an Overpayment, It Cannot Charge Interest on the Same Money

A taxpayer overpayment already held by the government must reduce later deficiency interest; the BIR cannot charge interest on funds it should credit or refund. Taxpayers who overpay taxes by mistake are not automatically delinquent on the full amount of a later deficiency if the government was already holding money that rightfully belonged to them. […]

When Taxpayers Refuse to Show Their Books, the BIR May Reconstruct the Tax Due

When taxpayers withhold or fail to produce books, the BIR may reconstruct liability using the best evidence obtainable, and assessments are presumed correct. Taxpayers who refuse or fail to produce their books of accounts cannot expect a court to strike down a BIR assessment merely because the BIR relied on indirect evidence. Where tax records […]