When One Gunman Starts a Deadly Attack, All Conspirators May Answer for Murder

Group attackers may all face murder liability when conspiracy is proven through coordinated acts, even if each person’s exact role is not separately shown. A person who joins an armed group attack may be convicted not only for the shot he personally fired, but for the killing carried out by the group when the evidence […]

When Inconsistent Conduct Creates Reasonable Doubt in a Criminal Trial

The Court acquitted an accused where uncorroborated testimony and surrounding facts created reasonable doubt, reaffirming the presumption of innocence. Criminal convictions cannot rest on testimony that leaves the court with serious, reasonable doubt. Even in a prosecution involving a grave accusation, the constitutional presumption of innocence prevails when the complainant’s account is uncorroborated and the […]

Confessions Without Counsel Cannot Convict: Why Galit Still Protects Suspects Under Custodial Investigation

Confessions taken without meaningful counsel and clear rights warnings are inadmissible; Galit’s conviction was reversed for custodial rights violations. A confession taken from a suspect without meaningful access to counsel is not merely weak evidence; it is inadmissible evidence. For persons accused of crimes, People v. Galit is a stark reminder that police shortcuts during […]

A Wounded Victim’s Statement Can Still Convict Even When It Is Not a True Dying Declaration

A victim statement may fail as a dying declaration but still be admitted as res gestae if made immediately after the attack before fabrication was possible. A victim’s statement identifying the shooter is not automatically admissible as a dying declaration; but if made immediately after the attack, before there is time to fabricate a story, […]

When a Confession Can Convict: The Ramos Rule on Voluntary Admissions, Corroboration, and Trial Court Credibility

Ramos explains when a confession can support conviction: voluntariness, corroboration, physical evidence, and trial court credibility findings may defeat later denial. A criminal confession can sustain a conviction when the courts are satisfied that it was voluntary, consistent with independent physical evidence, and supported by details that only the offender would likely know. For accused […]

When a Group Attack Proves Conspiracy but Not Murder

Group conduct proved conspiracy in a prison killing, but the Court reduced murder to homicide because treachery and evident premeditation were not proven. Coordinated participation in a fatal attack can establish conspiracy even without a written plan or spoken agreement, but murder still requires proof of the facts that qualify the killing as murder. In […]

Self-Defense Does Not Require Perfect Proportionality When the Threat Is Immediate

The Court acquitted an accused who used a gun against an armed attacker, holding that self-defense does not require exact weapon proportionality. A person who reacts to an imminent armed attack is not judged by the calm arithmetic of hindsight. In Lacson, the Court recognized a practical self-defense rule: when danger is sudden, real, and […]