Inherited Shares in Family Corporations Must Pass Through Estate Settlement First

Heirs disputing family corporation shares must settle estate rights first; GIS entries alone do not prove ownership or create an intra-corporate case. Heirs fighting over shares in a family corporation cannot convert an inheritance dispute into an intra-corporate case merely because the property involved consists of corporate shares. When the claimed shares came from a […]

Inherited Shares Are Not Automatically Corporate Shares: Why Estate Settlement Comes First

Heirs do not automatically become stockholders over inherited shares; estate settlement and stock transfer book registration must come first. Heirs who inherit shares in a family corporation do not automatically become stockholders with enforceable corporate rights. Before a disputed transfer of inherited shares can be treated as an intra-corporate controversy, the estate must first be […]

Shareholder Derivative Suits Can Be Dismissed When Investors Skip Internal Corporate Remedies

Minority shareholders must plead specific exhausted corporate remedies before filing a derivative suit; letters and meetings alone may not be enough. Minority stockholders cannot use a derivative suit as a first resort when they have not pleaded, with particularity, the internal corporate remedies they tried and failed to exhaust. For business owners, directors, corporate secretaries, […]

Derivative Suits Can Be Dismissed When Stockholders Skip Appraisal Rights Allegations

Stockholders’ derivative suit over a corporate mortgage was dismissed for failing to plead appraisal rights and non-harassment requirements. Stockholders who sue in the corporation’s name cannot treat a derivative suit as a shortcut around corporate remedies. When the challenged corporate act involves the sale, mortgage, or disposition of substantially all corporate assets, the complaint must […]

Majority Stockholders Cannot Use Derivative Suits to Bypass the Board

Majority stockholders cannot use derivative suits to bypass board authority when a corporation can sue in its own name over corporate property. Majority stockholders who control a corporation cannot sue in a derivative capacity merely because a corporate asset was allegedly misused. If the corporation can act through its board, the proper plaintiff is the […]

Non-Stock Associations Cannot Expel Members or Transfer Community Property Without Due Process and Corporate Purpose

The Supreme Court voided improper association expulsions and land transfers, protecting members’ due process, inspection rights, and corporate property. Members of a non-stock association are not powerless when officers remove them without notice or transfer association property to insiders. The Supreme Court confirmed that membership cannot be terminated by shortcut, and corporate property cannot be […]

Shareholder Lawsuits Over Unfinished Corporate Projects Must Go to the Right Commercial Court

Shareholder derivative suits over corporate projects must be filed in special commercial courts and must strictly plead exhaustion and other requisites. A shareholder who sues on behalf of a corporation cannot avoid the special rules for derivative suits by labeling the case as one for specific performance. When the complaint seeks to enforce a corporate […]

Receivership Is Not a Shortcut in Corporate Control Disputes: Courts Need Evidence Before Taking Over a Company

Receivership requires proof of imminent asset loss and business paralysis; suspicion of fraud and failed settlement are not enough to displace corporate management. A corporate dissenter cannot force a court-supervised takeover of a school, family corporation, or closely held company merely by alleging fraud, missing funds, or internal mismanagement. The party asking for a receiver […]

When a Defective Board Approval Can Still Bind the Corporation

A defective board approval may still bind a corporation when stockholders later ratify the sale with sufficient voting power. A corporation may still be bound by a property sale even when the original board meeting authorizing the transaction was defective, if the stockholders later ratify the act with the required voting power. For business owners, […]

When a Stockholder Cannot Personally Sue for Corporate Losses: The Derivative Suit Rule That Protects Company Claims

A shareholder cannot personally sue for corporate losses unless a proper derivative suit is filed in the corporation’s name with required parties joined. A stockholder who complains that corporate assets were diverted, waived, or wasted cannot automatically sue in his own name. When the alleged injury belongs to the corporation, the claim must generally be […]