Intervention Is Not a Second Chance: Why Shareholders Need Proper Authority Before Fighting Corporate Property Cases

Shareholders and intervenors cannot appeal corporate property disputes without party status or board authority; intervention falls when the main case is dismissed. Shareholders, heirs, and corporate insiders cannot revive a lost corporate property dispute by appealing in their own names when they were merely intervenors, were not parties to the surviving case, or were never […]

When Damage Awards in Corporate Cases Cannot Be Collected While an Appeal Is Pending

Moral damages, exemplary damages, and attorney’s fees in intra-corporate cases cannot be immediately executed while appeal remains pending. Parties who win moral damages, exemplary damages, or attorney’s fees in an intra-corporate case cannot automatically collect those amounts while the losing party’s appeal is still pending. Even if intra-corporate decisions are generally immediately executory, the Supreme […]

When Corporate Property Is Misused, Minority Stockholders May Sue Where the Company Is Based

Minority stockholders may file derivative suits at the corporation’s principal office when insiders allegedly misuse corporate property and board action is futile. Minority stockholders are not powerless when controlling insiders allegedly mortgage, encumber, or allow the foreclosure of corporate property without authority. If the injury belongs to the corporation and the board is unwilling or […]

Shareholder Disputes Cannot Be Turned Into Corporate Liquidation Cases by Shortcut

A derivative suit cannot be converted into liquidation. Stockholders must exhaust corporate remedies and properly plead inspection, evidence, and dissolution claims. Stockholders who accuse fellow owners or directors of misusing corporate assets must file the correct corporate remedy and comply with its strict prerequisites; they cannot use a derivative suit as a shortcut to force […]

Heirs Cannot Use a Corporate Case to Divide Inherited Shares Before Estate Settlement

Heirs disputing inherited corporate shares must pursue estate settlement, not a commercial or derivative suit, when the real issue is succession and partition. Heirs claiming ownership of shares in a family corporation cannot shortcut probate by filing a corporate case for accounting, derivative relief, or alleged corporate fraud. When the real dispute is who among […]

When Stockholders Can Sue Directors but Still Lose: The Business Judgment Shield in Corporate Mismanagement Cases

Stockholders may file derivative suits for corporate injury, but directors are not liable for board decisions absent proof of bad faith, malice, fraud, or loss. Corporate directors are not personally liable merely because a stockholder disagrees with their hiring, compensation, or management decisions. A derivative suit may allow a shareholder to sue on behalf of […]

A Corporate Officer Cannot Force a Criminal Case Without Authority From the Company

A corporate officer cannot force prosecutors to file a criminal case for a company claim without proper authority from the corporation. Corporate officers, minority shareholders, and directors cannot use a criminal complaint to recover a company claim unless they can show authority to act for the corporation. Even when a prosecutor commits a procedural mistake, […]

You Cannot File a Derivative Suit Unless You First Prove You Are a Stockholder

A derivative suit fails if the claimant cannot prove stockholder status at the time of the disputed corporate acts, even where fraud is alleged. Serious accusations of fraud, mismanagement, and dissipation of corporate assets will not be heard through a derivative suit unless the person suing first proves the most basic requirement: that he or […]

Director Compensation Is Not Automatically Illegal When It Pays for Corporate Officer Services

Directors cannot be paid merely for board service, but compensation may be valid when paid for separate corporate officer work authorized by the company. Corporate directors are generally not entitled to pay merely for sitting on the board, but they may lawfully receive compensation when they perform separate work as corporate officers. For companies, schools, […]