Judges Cannot Cut Off an Appeal Just Because an Accused Has Started Serving Sentence

A timely notice of appeal cannot be denied merely because the accused began serving sentence; judges may be fined for confusing final judgments with executory ones. A criminal conviction does not become final merely because an accused begins serving sentence after judgment. Where a notice of appeal is filed within the reglementary period, the appeal […]

A Bad Court Decision Is Usually Appealed, Not Turned Into a Case Against the Judge

Judicial error is generally corrected by appeal, not discipline. A judge is liable only upon proof of bad faith, corruption, fraud, or deliberate injustice. Parties who believe a judge made a wrong decision generally must use the ordinary judicial remedies first, such as reconsideration or appeal, instead of immediately filing an administrative case against the […]

Judges Cannot Borrow Tax Officers as Sheriffs: Why Court Authority Has Limits

A judge was disciplined for letting a finance/tax agency employee act as sheriff, reinforcing that court execution must be done only by authorized court personnel. Courts cannot turn executive-branch employees into court sheriffs simply because a judge believes it is convenient. For litigants enforcing judgments, this ruling matters because the validity, integrity, and fairness of […]

A Desistance Affidavit Cannot End a Public Crime Without Prosecutorial Scrutiny

Affidavit of desistance cannot alone dismiss a public crime; the judge was fined for mishandling preliminary investigation records. Victims and heirs cannot privately erase a criminal case simply by signing an affidavit of desistance, especially when the offense charged is a public crime. In Padua v. Judge Molina, the Supreme Court made clear that judges […]

When the Complaint Does Not Allege a Non-Bailable Firearms Offense, Bail Cannot Be Denied by Assumption

A judge was cleared for granting bail where the firearms complaint did not allege the qualifying circumstance needed to make the charge non-bailable. An accused cannot be treated as facing a non-bailable firearms offense simply because a firearm was allegedly connected to a killing. The charging document must expressly allege the qualifying circumstance that makes […]

When a Judge Ignores a Mandatory Reporting Duty, It Becomes Administrative Misconduct

Judges must obey clear statutory duties when issuing injunctions; failure to report as required may result in administrative liability despite other remedies. Judges cannot treat statutory reporting duties as optional, especially when the law directs immediate notice to the Supreme Court after issuing an injunction. In Calleja v. Judge Santelices, the Court made clear that […]

Judges Are Not Automatically Liable for Granting Bail During Preliminary Investigation

Bail remains a matter of right before formal court charging, and judges are not liable for bail orders absent fraud, bad faith, or corruption. Judges are not administratively liable simply because they grant bail before a criminal case is formally filed in court, even when the accusation is serious. The practical rule is important for […]

When a Court Order Reaches Non-Parties, Judges Can Be Sanctioned for Ignoring Jurisdiction

A judge was fined for issuing a writ of possession affecting non-parties, reinforcing due process, jurisdiction limits, and remedies in property enforcement. Judges cannot use a writ of possession to eject people who were never parties to the case and whose rights were never heard. When a court enforces a judgment against strangers to the […]