Judicial Errors Are Not Misconduct: When a Losing Party Cannot Turn a Court Ruling Into an Administrative Case

The Supreme Court held that alleged judicial errors cannot support discipline without proof of bad faith, dishonesty, corruption, or gross ignorance. A party who believes a judge made a wrong ruling must generally use the proper judicial remedy, not an administrative complaint, unless the alleged error is shown to be tainted by fraud, dishonesty, corruption, […]

Expired Lease, No Injunction: Why Courts Cannot Stop Eviction Without a Clear Legal Right

Courts cannot issue injunctions over expired leases without a clear legal right; procedural shortcuts in summary cases may expose judges to discipline. Businesses, property owners, and government corporations defending possession of leased premises gain an important reminder from this ruling: a court cannot use a temporary restraining order or preliminary injunction to protect a tenant […]

Judges Cannot Notarize the Same Cohabitation Affidavits They Rely On to Solemnize Marriage

Judges cannot notarize cohabitation affidavits they later rely on to solemnize license-free marriages; doing so is gross ignorance of the law. Parties relying on the five-year cohabitation exception to the marriage license requirement must have their affidavit sworn before a proper officer other than the judge who will solemnize the marriage. The ruling makes clear […]

Lawyers Cannot Turn Lost Remedies Into Administrative Cases Against Judges

A lawyer cannot use an administrative complaint as a substitute for appeal or certiorari when challenging foreclosure and writ of possession rulings. A lawyer who misses or disagrees with a court ruling cannot convert that legal setback into an administrative case against the judge or court personnel. The doctrine is simple but important: judicial errors […]

Judges Cannot Slow Down Ejectment Cases by Sending Them Back to the Barangay

Unlawful detainer cases must move quickly. Judges may be disciplined for delaying summary proceedings by improperly referring them back to barangay conciliation. Property owners and occupants in unlawful detainer cases are entitled to a fast court ruling, and a judge cannot use barangay conciliation as a detour when the case is already governed by the […]

When a Judgment Becomes Final, the Winning Party Has the Right to Execution

A final judgment must be executed as a matter of right; delaying a writ without legal basis can expose a judge to discipline for gross ignorance and delay. A winning litigant should not have to relitigate a case after the judgment has become final. Once a court decision is final and executory, execution becomes a […]

When a Judge Has Family Ties to a Criminal Complainant, Inhibition Is Not Optional

Judges with disqualifying family ties must inhibit even during preliminary investigation when probable cause, warrants, and bail may affect liberty. A judge who is related to a party or interested complainant cannot cure the conflict by saying he was only conducting a preliminary investigation. When the judge must determine probable cause, issue a warrant, recommend […]