When a Manager Is Not a Corporate Officer: Why Employers Cannot Avoid Illegal Dismissal Claims by Using a Board Resolution

A stockholder-manager is not automatically a corporate officer. Without proof of board appointment, an illegal dismissal claim remains with the Labor Arbiter. A company cannot convert an employee’s illegal dismissal case into an intra-corporate dispute merely by calling the employee a manager, pointing to his stock ownership, or terminating him through a board resolution. If […]

When Damage Awards in Corporate Cases Cannot Be Collected While an Appeal Is Pending

Moral damages, exemplary damages, and attorney’s fees in intra-corporate cases cannot be immediately executed while appeal remains pending. Parties who win moral damages, exemplary damages, or attorney’s fees in an intra-corporate case cannot automatically collect those amounts while the losing party’s appeal is still pending. Even if intra-corporate decisions are generally immediately executory, the Supreme […]

Dissenting Stockholders Cannot Force a Buyout Unless the Corporation Has Retained Earnings

Dissenting stockholders may demand fair value, but payment is enforceable only when the corporation has unrestricted retained earnings to protect creditors. A dissenting stockholder’s appraisal right is not an automatic right to immediate cash. Even after a valid objection to a corporate amendment and even after an appraisal committee fixes the fair value of the […]

Minority Stockholders Can Inspect Corporate Records Unless the Corporation Proves Bad Faith

Minority stockholders may inspect corporate books unless the corporation proves bad faith, improper use, or illegitimate purpose. Minority stockholders do not have to prove their good faith before they can inspect corporate books; the corporation that refuses inspection must prove improper motive, bad faith, or illegitimate purpose. That rule matters in tax, corporate governance, and […]

When Corporate Property Is Misused, Minority Stockholders May Sue Where the Company Is Based

Minority stockholders may file derivative suits at the corporation’s principal office when insiders allegedly misuse corporate property and board action is futile. Minority stockholders are not powerless when controlling insiders allegedly mortgage, encumber, or allow the foreclosure of corporate property without authority. If the injury belongs to the corporation and the board is unwilling or […]

Shareholder Disputes Cannot Be Turned Into Corporate Liquidation Cases by Shortcut

A derivative suit cannot be converted into liquidation. Stockholders must exhaust corporate remedies and properly plead inspection, evidence, and dissolution claims. Stockholders who accuse fellow owners or directors of misusing corporate assets must file the correct corporate remedy and comply with its strict prerequisites; they cannot use a derivative suit as a shortcut to force […]

Corporate Officers Cannot Convert Removal Disputes Into Labor Cases

A corporate officer named in the by-laws must challenge removal in the proper commercial court, not before the Labor Arbiter or NLRC. A vice president named in a corporation’s by-laws cannot treat removal from office as an ordinary illegal dismissal case before the Labor Arbiter. When the position is a corporate office, the dispute belongs […]

Corporate Books, GIS Filings, and Family Business Disputes: When Denying Inspection Can Become Criminal

A pending accounting case does not defeat stockholder inspection rights, and false GIS shareholding entries may support falsification and perjury charges. A corporation cannot defeat a stockholder’s right to inspect corporate records merely by pointing to a pending accounting dispute. For family corporations, closely held companies, and businesses with contested control, the ruling draws a […]

Heirs Cannot Use a Corporate Case to Divide Inherited Shares Before Estate Settlement

Heirs disputing inherited corporate shares must pursue estate settlement, not a commercial or derivative suit, when the real issue is succession and partition. Heirs claiming ownership of shares in a family corporation cannot shortcut probate by filing a corporate case for accounting, derivative relief, or alleged corporate fraud. When the real dispute is who among […]