A Corporation Cannot Keep Two Stock and Transfer Books: SEC Control Over Corporate Records Matters for Tax and Ownership Disputes

The Court upheld SEC authority to cancel a duplicate stock and transfer book, clarifying how corporate records affect ownership, authority, and tax-sensitive transactions. Corporate ownership records can decide who controls a company, who may act for it, and whose records tax and regulatory authorities may rely upon. In Provident International Resources Corporation v. Venus, the […]

When Corporate Elections Are Contested, the SEC May Still Act

A corporate election case does not stop the SEC from exercising retained regulatory powers, and election contests must be filed within 15 days. A pending corporate election dispute does not automatically freeze all regulatory action involving the corporation. Stockholders and directors fighting over control may go to court over the validity of meetings, elections, or […]

When Corporate Asset Sales Go Wrong: Property Recovery Cases Belong in Court, Not the SEC

The Supreme Court held that a corporation’s property recovery suit against a receiver’s alleged unauthorized sale belongs in the RTC, not the SEC. A corporation that seeks to recover real property allegedly sold without authority by its rehabilitation receiver may file an ordinary court action for reconveyance, annulment of sale, and damages; the dispute does […]

Corporate Officers Can Bring Compensation and Stock Benefit Disputes Before the SEC

Corporate officer compensation and stock benefit claims may be intra-corporate disputes, while parent companies remain separate absent grounds to pierce the veil. Corporate executives who are also officers, directors, or shareholders may have a corporate controversy—not just an ordinary labor dispute—when unpaid salaries, retirement benefits, stock options, or other compensation claims arise from their corporate […]

Family Corporations, Land Transfers, and the Limits of Piercing the Corporate Veil

Family corporations remain separate from shareholders absent proof of fraud; late documentary stamp tax objections will not automatically void share transfers. Family-owned corporations cannot be disregarded merely because relatives used them to hold land, transfer shares, or structure estate-related arrangements. A party asking a court to treat corporate property as personally owned must prove that […]

Certified True Copies in Certiorari Petitions: Why One Missing Stamp Should Not Defeat a Meritorious Appeal

Certiorari petitions need certified true copies of the assailed ruling, not every annex. Van Melle protects meritorious appeals from technical dismissal. Litigants challenging a court, tribunal, or agency ruling by certiorari do not need to secure certified true copies of every pleading and attachment in the record. What must be certified is the judgment, order, […]

A Stock Certificate Is Not Ownership: Why Corporate Books Still Control Share Transfer Disputes

A private share endorsement cannot force stock certificate issuance unless the transfer is recorded in the corporate stock and transfer book. Corporate shareholders cannot force a corporation to issue stock certificates in their name merely by showing a private endorsement or deed of transfer. The decisive step is registration in the corporation’s stock and transfer […]

Stock Transfers Must Be Registered Before Buyers Can Vote or Control the Corporation

Share buyers cannot vote against the corporation until transfers are recorded in corporate books; injunction may preserve control during disputes. A buyer of corporate shares does not automatically become a voting stockholder against the corporation simply because a deed of sale has been signed. Until the transfer is recorded in the corporate books, the corporation […]

When a Stockholder’s Loan Becomes Paid-In Surplus, the Fight Belongs Before the SEC

A shareholder’s ₱25M paid-in surplus dispute was an intra-corporate controversy for the SEC, not an ordinary collection case before trial courts. A dispute over whether a shareholder’s multi-million-peso infusion should remain in a corporation’s books as paid-in surplus, or be restored as an enforceable loan, is not an ordinary collection case when the controversy arises […]

Homeowners’ Association Leadership Disputes Belong Before the Housing Regulator, Not the Regular Trial Courts

Homeowners’ association leadership and election disputes must go to the proper housing regulator, not regular courts, when control of the association is at issue. Homeowners and neighborhood associations cannot treat an election fight, board takeover, or rival association dispute as an ordinary civil case merely by adding damages or asking a trial court to remove […]