When Unpaid Shares Are Sold, the Forum Matters: Intra-Corporate Stock Disputes Belong in the Special Commercial Court

Unpaid stock subscription and delinquency sale disputes are intra-corporate cases for Special Commercial Courts, with strict certiorari rules still applying. Shareholders contesting the sale of delinquent shares must treat the dispute as an intra-corporate controversy, not as an ordinary collection or damages case. The Suzuki ruling matters because it confirms that fights over unpaid stock […]

A Corporation Cannot Escape Member Suits by Claiming It Was Dormant or Informally Dissolved

Members expelled without due process may pursue an intra-corporate case despite claims of dormancy or informal dissolution by corporate officers. Corporate officers and association leaders cannot defeat a member’s complaint simply by saying the organization was dormant, unregistered in practice, or already informally dissolved. Where members sue officers over expulsion from membership, loss of franchise […]

Director Compensation Is Not Automatically Illegal When It Pays for Corporate Officer Services

Directors cannot be paid merely for board service, but compensation may be valid when paid for separate corporate officer work authorized by the company. Corporate directors are generally not entitled to pay merely for sitting on the board, but they may lawfully receive compensation when they perform separate work as corporate officers. For companies, schools, […]

Corporations Cannot Sue Unless Their Board Authorizes the Case

A corporation cannot sue through officers or lawyers without board authority. Premium Marble confirms that corporate litigation must be backed by proper authorization. A corporation may lose its day in court if the lawsuit is filed without authority from its board of directors. In Premium Marble, the Supreme Court made clear that a corporation’s power […]

When a Corporate Officer Is Removed, the Labor Arbiter May Not Be the Right Forum

Corporate officers removed from board-created posts may belong in an intra-corporate forum, not the NLRC, even when they seek reinstatement and backwages. A corporate officer who is removed from an elected or appointed corporate post cannot automatically treat the dispute as an ordinary illegal dismissal case before the Labor Arbiter. When the controversy is rooted […]

Removed Corporate Trustees May Still Recover Damages Even When Reinstatement Becomes Moot

An unlawfully ousted trustee may still recover damages even when reinstatement becomes moot because the office term has expired. A corporate officer or trustee who was unlawfully ousted is not automatically left without a remedy merely because the term of office has already expired. When reinstatement is no longer possible because the office term has […]

When a Stock Sale Fight Belongs Before the SEC, Not the Trial Court

Share transfer and corporate control disputes belong before the SEC when they affect ownership, voting rights, directors, and corporate governance. Corporate control disputes cannot be disguised as ordinary civil cases when the real fight is over who owns, votes, records, or controls shares in a corporation. The doctrine from the Abejo-Braga controversy is straightforward but […]