Directors cannot be paid merely for board service, but compensation may be valid when paid for separate corporate officer work authorized by the company.

Corporate directors are generally not entitled to pay merely for sitting on the board, but they may lawfully receive compensation when they perform separate work as corporate officers. For companies, schools, family corporations, and closely held businesses, the practical lesson is direct: compensation must be documented as payment for real officer functions, not disguised director fees.

Why This Case Matters to Corporate Taxpayers and Business Owners

Disputes over director compensation often arise inside corporations where shareholders, directors, and officers are the same or related persons. The issue is not merely internal politics. Once compensation is attacked as unauthorized, the corporation may face civil claims for refund, criminal accusations, governance disputes, and, in tax practice, questions about whether the payments were properly characterized, approved, and recorded.

Western Institute of Technology involved a private educational corporation whose minority members challenged payments made to controlling members of the Board of Trustees. Although the case was litigated through criminal and civil procedure, its continuing importance for corporate and tax advisers lies in its treatment of compensation. The Court distinguished prohibited compensation for acting as a director or trustee from permissible compensation for services performed in another corporate capacity.

Background: The Board Resolution and the Challenge

The controversy began when the Board of Trustees of Western Institute of Technology passed a resolution granting monthly compensation to certain corporate officers retroactive to June 1, 1985. The resolution identified the recipients by officer positions, including Chairman, Vice-Chairman, Secretary, and Treasurer, and also provided for a percentage share from profits to be distributed among them.

Minority shareholders later filed criminal complaints for falsification of a public document and estafa, alleging that the resolution had been improperly represented as having been passed at a board meeting and that the payments were unauthorized. After trial, the accused were acquitted. The petitioners then sought to impose civil liability against the private respondents for the amounts allegedly received under the resolution. The Supreme Court addressed the dispute in Western Institute of Technology, Inc. v. Salas (G.R. No. 113032, August 21, 1997).

The Core Doctrine: No Pay for Being a Director, But Pay May Be Allowed for Officer Work

The controlling statutory rule was Section 30 of the Corporation Code. As the Court explained, directors or trustees are not, as a general rule, entitled to salary or compensation when they perform only the ordinary functions of a director or trustee. The law permits reasonable per diems, and it also allows compensation when the by-laws provide for it or when stockholders representing at least a majority of the outstanding capital stock approve it at a regular or special meeting.

But the Court refused to treat the statutory restriction as a sweeping ban on all compensation received by persons who also sit on the board. The phrase limiting compensation to directors


Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *