Redundancy Is Not a Shortcut: Employers Must Prove the Business Need Before Ending a Job

Redundancy requires substantial proof. A BPO employee’s dismissal was illegal where the employer failed to prove business need and imposed a prejudicial transfer. Employees dismissed for redundancy may challenge the termination when the employer cannot prove, with real business evidence, that their work has become excessive or unnecessary. A company cannot rely on management discretion […]

When a Merger Brings Workers Into a Unionized Company, the CBA May Follow Them

Absorbed employees in a merger may be covered by the surviving company’s union shop clause, affecting CBA compliance and workforce integration. Companies that acquire or absorb another business through merger cannot treat incoming employees as a separate class outside the surviving company’s existing collective bargaining agreement. When absorbed workers become regular employees of a unionized […]

Government-Owned Subsidiaries Cannot Escape Labor Law When Employees Are Illegally Dismissed

Employees of GOCC subsidiaries without original charters may sue before labor tribunals when dismissed without due process, reinstatement, and backwages. Employees of government-owned or controlled corporations organized under the general corporation law are not automatically civil service employees; when they are dismissed without due process, their remedy may still lie before labor tribunals, with reinstatement, […]

When Labor Picketing Spills Over to a Neighboring Business, the RTC May Step In

A non-employer affected by strike activity may seek RTC relief when no labor dispute or employment relationship is shown with the union. A business that is not proven to be the employer of striking workers may ask the regular courts for relief when picketing or strike activity affects its premises. The key practical lesson is […]

Official Errands Can Be Compensable Even Outside Work Hours

Work-related errands may be compensable even outside office hours or premises when the injury is connected to official duties and evidence is unrebutted. Employees injured while performing a work-related errand may still be entitled to employees’ compensation even if the accident happens outside regular office hours, away from the workplace, or on a day when […]

When a Bank Becomes Liable for a Security Guard’s Work Injury Compensation

A bank hiring agency guards was liable as statutory employer for death benefits, but the security agency had to reimburse it under their contract. A business that hires agency personnel may still be treated as the worker’s statutory employer for workmen’s compensation, even if the service contract says the worker belongs exclusively to the agency. […]

Work-Related Illness Claims Become Easier When the Employer Cannot Disprove Work Aggravation

A worker’s stroke was compensable because illness arising during employment is presumed work-connected unless the employer proves otherwise. Employees whose illness emerges or worsens during employment may still recover workmen’s compensation even when the disease is not shown to have been directly caused by the job, if the employer fails to overcome the legal presumption […]

When Illness Appears During Employment, the Employer Must Prove It Is Not Work-Related

Illness arising during employment is presumed compensable unless the employer proves otherwise, protecting workers in sickness and disability claims. Employees who become sick while still in service are not required to prove with mathematical certainty that their work caused the illness. Under the compensability presumption applied in Dimdiman, once the illness supervenes during employment, the […]