When Absences Are Used as a Pretext: Union Activity Can Make a Dismissal Illegal

The Court held that absences cannot justify dismissal when the real motive is union activity, and a good-faith unfair labor practice strike is not illegal. Employers cannot rely on a worker’s absences as a shield if the real reason for dismissal is union activity. The practical rule is simple but powerful: a company may have […]

When Government Review Can Revive a Dismissed Employee Appeal

The Court upheld presidential review of a labor appeal and sustained dismissal of a managerial employee for loss of confidence based on a concrete breach of trust. A labor appeal is not defeated simply because the employee describes the ruling as contrary to law, unsupported by evidence, or gravely injurious to his rights. When the […]

When Equal Pay Becomes a Legal Duty: What Employers Must Know About Wage Inequities and Collective Bargaining

PNR confirms that wage inequities may justify salary adjustments when comparable employees are treated unevenly and management fails to bargain in good faith. Employers cannot defeat wage-standardization claims simply by saying the company has limited funds, especially when the record shows that similarly situated employees in other departments received better treatment. Where employees performing comparable […]

When Illness Strikes at Work, the Employer Must Disprove Compensation

Illness arising during strenuous employment is presumed compensable unless the employer disproves work-connection and timely controverts the claim. Employees who fall ill while performing strenuous work may be entitled to compensation even when medical certainty is unavailable, because the law presumes compensability once the illness arises or worsens during employment. The burden is not on […]

When Job Stress Makes Illness Compensable: The Presumption That Protects Long-Serving Employees

Illness that appears during employment may be presumed compensable, shifting the burden to the employer to disprove work connection or aggravation. Employees who become ill while still in service do not always have to prove, with medical certainty, that their work alone caused the disease. Under the old Workmen’s Compensation regime applied in Flores, once […]

Employers Cannot Block a Union Vote by Turning Signature Disputes Into Technical Objections

Employers cannot block a certification election through technical signature objections when the labor authority finds voting is the best test of employee choice. Employers facing a certification election petition cannot defeat the workers’ choice of bargaining representative by relying on technical objections to the union’s initial signature count when the labor authority has sufficient basis […]

When Employers Miss the Deadline, Work Injury Claims Become Much Harder to Defeat

Illness arising during employment is presumed work-related, and an employer that fails to timely controvert may waive defenses to compensation. An employee who becomes ill while still in service does not always have to prove, from scratch, that the job caused the illness. Under the workmen’s compensation presumption applied in Ferrer, an illness that supervened […]

Workers Can Break Away From a Union and Demand a Certification Election

Workers who leave an incumbent union may form a new union and seek a certification election despite an existing CBA or prior bargaining agent. Employees who disaffiliate from an existing union are not trapped by a prior bargaining relationship: once their right to choose a new representative is put in issue, the proper remedy is […]