When a Firing Is Too Harsh: Minor Workplace Mistakes Cannot Automatically Cost an Employee Their Job

Dismissal must be proportionate to the offense; minor lapses may not justify termination, while corporate officer disputes belong outside the NLRC. Employers may discipline employees for mistakes, absence, delay, or failure to follow instructions, but dismissal remains a last-resort penalty: the misconduct must be serious, willful, work-related, and proportionate to the punishment imposed. Why This […]

When a Manager Is Not a Corporate Officer: Why Employers Cannot Avoid Illegal Dismissal Claims by Using a Board Resolution

A stockholder-manager is not automatically a corporate officer. Without proof of board appointment, an illegal dismissal claim remains with the Labor Arbiter. A company cannot convert an employee’s illegal dismissal case into an intra-corporate dispute merely by calling the employee a manager, pointing to his stock ownership, or terminating him through a board resolution. If […]

Ample Opportunity Rule: Due Process in Philippine Dismissals

Employee dismissal for loss of confidence requires substantial evidence, two notices, and a meaningful chance to answer charges. The Ample Opportunity Rule gives employers flexibility in disciplinary proceedings, but it does not excuse weak evidence, missing notices, or arbitrary dismissals. For Philippine labor law, the lesson is practical: an employee need not always receive a […]

Managerial Employees Can Be Removed for Loss of Trust—But Due Process Still Matters

Managerial employees may be dismissed for loss of trust on sufficient basis, but employers still owe notice and hearing before termination. Managers, deans, executives, and other employees entrusted with sensitive business functions may be dismissed on the ground of loss of trust and confidence even without criminal-level proof, but employers who skip notice and hearing […]

Retirement Benefits Cannot Be Denied by Arbitrary Management Discretion

Management discretion cannot defeat vested retirement benefits without due process, good faith, and clear compelling reasons. Corporate officers may be personally liable. Employers cannot defeat an employee’s vested retirement benefits by invoking management discretion as if it were unlimited power. When a retirement plan forms part of an employee’s compensation package, discretion must be exercised […]