Company lawyers may be employees under labor law, but loss of trust can justify dismissal if supported by facts and proper due process is observed.
In-house lawyers and corporate officers may be employees when the company controls their work, pays their salaries, and integrates them into its management structure; but because their positions depend on confidence, proven loss of trust can justify dismissal, subject always to the employee’s right to due process.
Why This Case Matters to Employers and In-House Counsel
Many companies treat senior legal officers differently from ordinary employees. They may be called vice presidents, legal advisers, corporate counsel, consultants, or retainers. But labels do not decide labor rights. What matters is the real relationship: who selected the person, who paid the compensation, who could dismiss the person, and whether the company had the right to control the work.
The ruling involving Equitable Banking Corporation and Ricardo Sadac is important because it addresses a recurring workplace question: can a company lawyer file an illegal dismissal case before the labor tribunals, or is the dispute merely a professional relationship governed by attorney-client rules? The Supreme Court answered that a lawyer may still be an employee, especially where the lawyer holds a corporate rank, receives regular pay and benefits, reports within the company structure, and performs duties that are part of the company’s regular operations.
Background: A Bank Lawyer, Internal Complaints, and a Forced Resignation
Ricardo Sadac was appointed Vice-President for Legal at Equitable Banking Corporation, later designated Vice-President and Legal Officer, with a monthly salary, allowance, private loan account, and a defined set of duties. His responsibilities included providing legal advice to the board and management, handling bank cases, supervising litigation, recovering past due accounts, recommending personnel actions in the legal department, and performing other duties assigned by the president and board.
After nine lawyers in the bank’s legal department complained about his alleged abusive conduct, mismanagement, inefficiency, indecisiveness, and ineffectiveness, the bank investigated. A memorandum from the board chairman asked Sadac to resign, stating that the board had lost confidence in him. Sadac denied the accusations and requested a formal hearing, but the bank took the position that no hearing was necessary because the matter involved loss of confidence in a sensitive legal position. The dispute eventually reached the Supreme Court in Equitable Banking Corporation v. NLRC (G.R. No. 102467, January 13, 1997).
The Core Doctrine: Control, Not Job Title, Determines Employment
The Supreme Court held that an employer-employee relationship existed between the bank and Sadac. The Court applied the familiar four-fold test: selection and engagement of the employee, payment of wages, power of dismissal, and power of control over the employee’s conduct. The most important element is control, meaning the right to control not only the result of the work but also the means and methods by which the work is performed.
For employers, the lesson is direct: calling someone a lawyer, consultant, adviser, or officer does not automatically remove the person from labor law protection. In this case, the bank appointed Sadac as vice-president, paid him a fixed monthly salary and benefits, required him to perform regular legal and managerial functions, placed him within the bank’s organizational structure, and used his work in ordinary bank operations. These facts supported the existence of employment.
At the same time, the Court emphasized that an in-house lawyer may still be subject to the company’s trust standards. A company lawyer is not merely an outside counsel handling an isolated matter. When the lawyer is part of the organization, supervises legal staff, handles sensitive litigation, advises management, and represents the company in disputes, the relationship necessarily requires confidence.
Loss of Trust Can Justify Dismissal, But It Must Rest on Facts
The Supreme Court recognized that loss of trust and confidence can be a valid ground for dismissal, especially for managerial employees and officers occupying positions of confidence. However, the employer’s claim cannot be a mere formula or convenient label. It must be based on clearly established facts showing conduct that makes the employee unfit to continue holding the position.
In Sadac’s case, the Court found that the bank had factual basis for losing confidence in him. The complaints were not vague accusations made by strangers. They came from lawyers in the legal department who worked under him. They alleged concrete workplace problems: abusive conduct, poor supervision, mismanagement, inefficiency, and indecisiveness. The Court considered these matters relevant because Sadac’s position required leadership of the legal department, sound judgment, and the confidence of both management and subordinate lawyers.
The Court therefore rejected the view that the dismissal was substantively baseless. It held that the bank could not be forced to continue employing a senior legal officer in whom it had already lost confidence, especially where the loss of confidence arose from matters directly connected to the legal department’s performance and morale.
Due Process Still Applies Even When Trust Has Been Lost
The most practical part of the ruling is its warning to employers: even when there is a valid reason to dismiss an employee, the company must still comply with procedural due process. The employee must be informed of the specific acts or omissions charged and must be given a meaningful opportunity to explain.
The bank argued that a formal hearing was unnecessary because the position involved confidence and because the board had already determined that the relationship could no longer continue. The Supreme Court disagreed on procedure. It held that confidence-based termination does not erase the statutory requirement of notice and opportunity to be heard. A request for a hearing, especially when repeatedly made and ignored, should not be brushed aside simply because management believes dismissal is inevitable.
For HR managers and corporate decision-makers, this is the key operational point: substantive justification and procedural due process are separate questions. A company may have a valid ground to dismiss, yet still be held liable for failing to observe the proper termination process.
Corporate Officers Are Not Automatically Personally Liable
The ruling also addressed whether the bank’s directors and officers could be held personally liable. The Court said no. A corporation has a personality separate from its directors and officers. Personal liability may arise only in exceptional situations, such as when directors or officers act with malice or bad faith, vote for unlawful acts, are guilty of gross negligence, have conflicts of interest causing damage, consent to watered stock, or are made personally liable by law.
The Supreme Court found no sufficient basis to impose solidary liability on the individual officers and directors. Although the dismissal process was procedurally defective, the Court did not find that the directors acted with dishonest purpose, moral obliquity, oppression, or bad faith. This distinction matters for corporate clients: a mistaken or procedurally flawed dismissal does not automatically pierce the corporate veil or expose directors to personal liability.
What the Court Ultimately Awarded
The Supreme Court affirmed the finding that Sadac was an employee and that the labor tribunals had jurisdiction. It also recognized the bank’s basis for dismissal due to loss of trust and confidence. However, because the bank failed to observe procedural due process, Sadac was awarded limited relief. The Court ordered payment of backwages up to the applicable retirement point, retirement benefits under the relevant policy, and an additional amount as indemnity for the due process violation, while absolving the individual directors and officers from solidary liability.
The result is balanced: the employer was not compelled to reinstate a senior legal officer in whom it had lost confidence, but it was not allowed to ignore the mandatory procedure for termination. The doctrine protects both the employer’s right to preserve trust in sensitive positions and the employee’s right to fair process.
Practical Lessons for Philippine Employers
Companies should not assume that lawyers, consultants, or officers fall outside labor law merely because of their title. If the person is paid a regular salary, receives benefits, works within the company structure, and is subject to company control, labor tribunals may treat that person as an employee.
Employers should also document loss of trust with specific facts. Internal complaints, investigation reports, performance records, and written communications matter. The more sensitive the position, the more important it is to show that the alleged loss of confidence is tied to the employee’s actual duties and not to whim, retaliation, or personality conflict.
Most importantly, companies must still serve proper notices and give a real chance to respond. Even if management believes that continued employment is impossible, the process must be followed. A legally defensible dismissal requires both a valid ground and procedural fairness.
How Ablola, Saribong & Gueco Can Help
Ablola, Saribong & Gueco advises employers, executives, and professionals on termination disputes, loss of trust and confidence cases, labor compliance, corporate officer liability, and NLRC litigation. For companies, we help design defensible disciplinary processes before disputes escalate. For employees and officers, we assess whether a dismissal was both substantively and procedurally valid.
For assistance with employment disputes, corporate officer terminations, or labor litigation strategy, visit MakatiLawFirm.com and consult Ablola, Saribong & Gueco for practical, litigation-ready advice.