When a Judge Gets the Law Wrong: Why Judicial Error Is Not Automatically Misconduct

The Supreme Court held that a judgeโ€™s erroneous or inconsistent order is not misconduct absent gross ignorance, bad faith, dishonesty, fraud, or corruption. Judges may commit reversible error without being administratively punished, so long as the mistake is not a blatant disregard of basic law and is not attended by bad faith, dishonesty, fraud, corruption, […]

Cash Shortages Can Convict Accountable Officers Even Without Direct Proof of Pocketing the Money

Accountable officers may be convicted for malversation when public funds are received, audited short, demanded, and left unexplained without direct proof of personal use. Public officers who collect or hold government funds cannot defeat a malversation charge merely by saying there is no direct proof that they personally spent the missing money. Once the prosecution […]

When Supervening Events End a Tax Recovery Fight: Why Courts Will Not Decide Discovery Disputes That No Longer Matter

The Supreme Court dismissed the Republicโ€™s certiorari petition as moot after document inspection occurred and the recovery complaint was dismissed. Parties in tax recovery, forfeiture, and government asset cases cannot expect appellate courts to resolve procedural discovery fights after the underlying controversy has already been overtaken by later events. When the requested inspection has already […]

A Nullity Case Will Not Pause a Bigamy Trial in the Philippines

A pending nullity case will not suspend a bigamy prosecution; the accused must prove a void-marriage defense in the criminal trial itself. A spouse accused of bigamy cannot stop the criminal case merely by filing a separate petition to declare an earlier marriage void. If the accused believes the first marriage never legally existed, that […]

Court Clerks May Attend Official Conventions, But Court Calendars Must Keep Moving

Court clerks may attend the RTC COCAP convention on official time, but only with prior approval, no court-calendar disruption, and no court-funded expenses. Court personnel may be allowed to attend professional association conventions on official time, but that permission is not a blank check: attendance remains subject to prior approval, must not disrupt the court […]

Hierarchy of Courts Rule: Why Direct SC Petitions Can Fail

Direct SC petitions against government contracts need special reasons; fact-heavy PPP challenges belong in the proper lower forum. The hierarchy of courts rule remains a serious litigation barrier even in constitutional cases: parties challenging government infrastructure contracts must show special and important reasons before going directly to the Supreme Court, especially when the dispute requires […]

Renewable Energy Police Power: Why FIT Charges Were Upheld

FIT charges for renewable energy are valid police-power measures when tied to public welfare, lawful delegation, and sufficient due process safeguards in 2024. The Renewable Energy Police Power Doctrine confirms that electricity consumers may be required to share in renewable energy transition costs when the charge is regulatory, authorized by law, and supported by due […]

Notice-and-Hearing Rule: Valid Rail Fare Hikes in PH

Rail fare hikes require statutory notice and hearing, but remain valid when agencies substantially comply and show a non-arbitrary basis. The statutory notice-and-hearing rule means that government agencies cannot rely on general rule-making powers to bypass procedures expressly required by law. For commuters, regulated businesses, and public agencies, Syjuco v. Secretary Abaya confirms two things […]

Business Permit Fee Rule: Tax Exemption Is Not Permit Exemption

Tax exemptions do not erase business permit fees; unregistered ecozone locators may owe local permits, local taxes, duties, and regulatory fees too now. The Business Permit Fee Rule protects a cityโ€™s power to regulate businesses even when the business claims tax exemption. For companies operating in special economic zones, the practical consequence is direct: an […]