A pending nullity case will not suspend a bigamy prosecution; the accused must prove a void-marriage defense in the criminal trial itself.

A spouse accused of bigamy cannot stop the criminal case merely by filing a separate petition to declare an earlier marriage void. If the accused believes the first marriage never legally existed, that defense must be proved in the bigamy trial itself; the criminal court can receive evidence on the validity of the marriage and decide whether the prosecution may stand.

Why This Ruling Matters

The decision matters for people facing, filing, or defending bigamy complaints in the Philippines because it clarifies a common litigation tactic: using a pending nullity case as a reason to suspend the criminal case. The Court rejected that approach. A petition for declaration of nullity of marriage is not automatically a prejudicial question in a bigamy prosecution, even if both cases involve the validity of the same marriage.

For private complainants, the ruling prevents delay. The mere filing of a civil case for nullity will not freeze the criminal proceedings. For accused spouses, however, the ruling is not entirely adverse. It confirms that the accused may still argue, within the bigamy case, that the prior marriage was void from the beginning. The point is procedural but powerful: the defense exists, but it must be litigated in the criminal case rather than used as a detour to postpone it.

Background: Two Marriages, One Bigamy Case, and a Pending Nullity Petition

Antonio Florentino entered into a marriage with Marilou Jarmin in 1984. He later claimed that the first marriage ceremony never actually took place and that the parties merely signed a marriage contract without solemnization. Years later, in 1999, Antonio married Maria Victoria Natividad-Florentino. The spouses lived together, but Victoria later verified Antonio’s civil status and obtained a certification showing two marriages.

Antonio filed a petition for declaration of absolute nullity of his first marriage. Shortly after, Victoria filed a criminal complaint for bigamy. Antonio then moved to suspend the bigamy proceedings and defer arraignment, arguing that the pending nullity case was a prejudicial question. The trial court denied the motion. The Court of Appeals initially agreed, but later reversed itself and held that the nullity case justified suspension. The consolidated case reached the Supreme Court in Florentino (G.R. No. 255335, August 27, 2025).

The Doctrine: No Prejudicial Question When the Criminal Court Can Decide the Marriage Issue

The Court held that the pending nullity case did not constitute a prejudicial question requiring suspension of the bigamy case. Under Rule 111 of the Rules of Criminal Procedure, a prejudicial question exists when a previously instituted civil action involves an issue similar or intimately related to the criminal action, and the resolution of that civil issue determines whether the criminal action may proceed.

The Court emphasized that similarity is not enough. The civil issue must be so determinative that the criminal case cannot properly move forward without first waiting for the civil case. In bigamy prosecutions, that condition is not met when the accused claims that the first marriage was void. The criminal court itself may examine that issue because the validity of the first marriage is essential to determining whether the accused is guilty of bigamy.

In practical terms, the civil nullity case and the criminal bigamy case may involve overlapping facts, but they are not dependent in the way required for a prejudicial question. The criminal court need not wait for the family court to act. It can hear the prosecution’s evidence, receive the defense’s proof, and decide whether the accused’s prior marriage was valid for purposes of criminal liability.

How Pulido Changed the Bigamy Defense

The ruling builds on Pulido v. People, where the Court abandoned earlier restrictive doctrines and adopted the view that a void marriage may be raised as a defense in a bigamy prosecution even without a prior judicial declaration of nullity. This means an accused in a bigamy case is not barred from arguing that the first marriage was void ab initio simply because no separate final nullity judgment has yet been issued.

That doctrine has two sides. On one hand, it protects the accused by allowing a collateral attack on a void marriage in the criminal case. On the other hand, it removes the reason for suspension. Because the criminal court can already decide the validity issue as part of the bigamy trial, the accused cannot insist that the civil nullity case must first be resolved before the prosecution proceeds.

What the Court Did to the Court of Appeals Ruling

The Court partially granted the petitions filed by Victoria and the People of the Philippines. It reversed and set aside the Court of Appeals’ amended decision and resolution, and directed the Regional Trial Court of Makati City to proceed with the bigamy case with dispatch and in accordance with law.

The Court did not finally decide whether Antonio’s first marriage was valid or void. That factual and legal question remains for the trial court to determine based on evidence. What the Court decided was that Antonio could not use the pending nullity case to stop the criminal proceedings. His claim that the first marriage lacked a solemnizing officer is a possible defense, not a procedural bar to prosecution.

Practical Impact for Spouses, Accused Persons, and Private Complainants

For a spouse who discovers a prior marriage, this ruling strengthens the practical enforceability of a bigamy complaint. The accused cannot automatically delay arraignment or trial by filing a separate nullity petition. Prosecutors and private complainants may point to this decision when opposing motions to suspend based on alleged prejudicial questions in related marriage cases.

For an accused spouse, the ruling requires a more direct defense strategy. If the accused claims that the first marriage was void because there was no ceremony, no valid solemnizing officer, no marriage license, or some other essential defect, the accused must be prepared to prove that defense in the criminal case through competent testimonial and documentary evidence. A pending civil case may still matter, but it does not stop the criminal court from proceeding.

For counsel, the decision also underscores the need to distinguish between two questions: whether a marriage is void for purposes of a bigamy defense, and whether a final judgment of nullity is required for remarriage under Article 40 of the Family Code. The first may be addressed in the criminal case. The second remains critical for anyone who seeks to remarry legally.

The Key Takeaway

The doctrine may be stated simply: a pending nullity case is not a pause button for a bigamy case. A void marriage can be raised as a defense, but that defense belongs in the criminal trial unless and until a separate judgment becomes relevant on appeal or in another legally proper manner. Courts will not allow the mere filing of a civil nullity petition to become a strategy for delaying or evading criminal prosecution.

Need Help With a Bigamy, Nullity, or Criminal Litigation Issue?

Ablola, Saribong & Gueco assists clients in family law disputes, criminal litigation, marriage nullity proceedings, and related civil and criminal strategy. If you are facing a bigamy complaint, considering a declaration of nullity, or determining whether a marriage defect can be raised as a defense, our lawyers can help assess the evidence, procedural risks, and litigation options. Visit MakatiLawFirm.com to schedule a consultation with our Makati-based litigation team.


Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *