Tax Assessment Appeal Separation: CTA Remedies in Tax Evasion Cases

A tax evasion case does not automatically preserve a taxpayer’s CTA appeal from a BIR assessment; the FDDA must be separately challenged. Taxpayers facing both a tax evasion case and a disputed assessment must treat the assessment appeal as a separate CTA remedy. The Tax Assessment Appeal Separation Doctrine means that a criminal tax case […]

120+30-Day VAT Refund Rule: Why Timing Can Defeat Tax Claims

VAT refund claims must meet strict 120+30-day CTA deadlines and invoice rules; late or improperly supported claims may be denied. The 120+30-Day VAT Refund Rule can defeat even a documented refund claim: a taxpayer seeking unutilized input VAT must file its Court of Tax Appeals case within the strict statutory window and must support purchases […]

Void Ordinance Rule: When LGU Franchise Taxes Cannot Be Collected

LGUs cannot collect franchise taxes under a void municipal ordinance; later cityhood does not cure the invalid local tax assessment. Local governments cannot collect taxes from businesses unless the tax is imposed through a valid ordinance enacted by an LGU that had legal authority to impose that tax at the time of enactment. Under the […]

VAT Refund Strict Proof Rule: When Input VAT Cannot Be Refunded

Input VAT is not refundable as erroneously paid tax unless the claim fits the VAT refund rules and is strictly proven by evidence. The VAT Refund Strict Proof Rule means that a taxpayer cannot turn undeclared or unused input VAT into a cash refund simply by calling it an erroneous payment. For Philippine businesses, the […]

CTA Tax Jurisdiction Rule: Why Tax Injunctions Belong in the CTA

Tax and customs collection disputes belong in the CTA, not the RTC; wrong-forum injunctions risk dismissal and loss of relief. Taxpayers disputing customs duties, internal revenue taxes, or tax collection measures cannot avoid the Court of Tax Appeals by styling their case as an ordinary injunction case before a Regional Trial Court. The CTA Tax […]

Tax Abatement Termination Letter: When BIR Relief Becomes Final

BIR tax abatement is final only with a termination letter; payment forms alone do not close deficiency tax assessments. Taxpayers who apply for BIR tax abatement cannot treat an assessment as closed simply because they paid the basic tax or submitted abatement forms. Under the tax abatement termination letter doctrine, the assessment remains enforceable until […]

LOA Due Process Rule: When BIR VAT Assessments Become Void

BIR tax exams need a valid Letter of Authority; without it, VAT assessments are void, and HMO medical-use funds may be excluded. The LOA Due Process Rule gives taxpayers a powerful defense against unauthorized BIR assessments: if a revenue officer examines a taxpayer without a valid Letter of Authority, the resulting assessment is void. In […]

Strict Waiver Rule: Defective BIR Waivers Void Tax Assessments

BIR assessments beyond three years are void when waivers are defective and RELIEF discrepancies fail to prove fraud or intentional falsity. Tax assessments issued after the ordinary three-year period can be void when the BIR relies on defective waivers, and alleged discrepancies from computerized matching do not automatically prove fraud. The Strict Waiver Rule protects […]

Local Tax Ordinance Challenges: Why Procedure Can Defeat Tax Cases

Taxpayers challenging local tax ordinances must first use DOJ remedies and proper courts, or risk dismissal despite serious tax claims. Taxpayers challenging a local tax ordinance must usually go first to the Secretary of Justice and the proper lower court before asking the Supreme Court to intervene. The local tax ordinance procedure rule means that […]

When a Share Redemption Is Not a Taxable Dividend

Share redemption premiums are not automatically dividends. The Court allowed Goodyear’s refund and held no 15% FWT applied without unrestricted retained earnings. Companies that redeem shares from a foreign shareholder do not automatically owe dividend withholding tax merely because the redemption price exceeds par value. The controlling question is whether the payment is truly a […]