Payment Under Protest Is Not Enough for Local Business Tax Refunds

A holding company’s local tax challenge failed because payment under protest did not replace the required written refund claim with the city treasurer. Taxpayers disputing local business tax collections cannot rely on a payment under protest alone when the controversy is treated as a refund case. Where the local government’s demand does not qualify as […]

Airline Excise Tax Refunds Need More Than Franchise Exemption: Import Cost Proof Matters

Airline won a partial excise tax refund after proving franchise exemption, in-flight use, and lower import costs for selected alcohol imports. Airlines and importers claiming excise tax refunds cannot rely on a statutory tax exemption alone; they must prove, item by item, that the imported goods satisfy the conditions of the exemption and that the […]

Late Formal Offer of Evidence Can Defeat a Tax Assessment Appeal

A taxpayer lost reconsideration after late extension motions led to exclusion of its Formal Offer of Evidence in a BIR assessment appeal. Taxpayers contesting a BIR assessment before the Court of Tax Appeals must treat procedural deadlines as litigation-critical. A late motion to extend the filing of a Formal Offer of Evidence may result in […]

VAT Refunds for ROHQ Services Can Survive Rehashed BIR Objections

Court denied the Commissioner’s MR, leaving intact a VAT refund/tax credit win involving ROHQ services and zero-rated transactions under Section 108(B)(2). Taxpayers claiming VAT refunds or tax credits should not assume that a BIR administrative denial is the end of the case, especially where the Court of Tax Appeals is presented with sufficient evidence that […]

VAT Refund Claimants May Present Their Full Evidence in Court, Not Just What the BIR Reviewed

Tax court review of VAT refund claims is de novo, allowing full evidence beyond BIR findings; the Commissioner’s reconsideration was denied. Taxpayers pursuing VAT refunds or tax credit certificates should prepare their cases as full-blown court actions, not merely as narrow reviews of what the BIR accepted or rejected during the administrative stage. In this […]

Tax Refund Claims Can Survive Branch TIN Issues When BIR Form 2307 Identifies the Same Taxpayer

CWT refund upheld despite branch TIN issues; BIR Forms 2307 may prove withholding when they identify the same taxpayer and support consolidated filing. Businesses claiming refunds of excess creditable withholding tax should not automatically lose a valid refund merely because some BIR Forms No. 2307 were issued under branch codes, provided the certificates sufficiently identify […]

VAT Refund Denied When Zero-Rated Sales and Official Receipts Do Not Match

A VAT refund claim was denied because the taxpayer failed to reconcile official receipts, billing statements, remittances, and VAT returns for zero-rated sales. Taxpayers claiming a VAT refund or tax credit for zero-rated sales must be able to connect every claimed sale, official receipt, billing statement, inward remittance, and VAT return entry with clear and […]

Taxpayers Seeking Excise Tax Refunds Gain Finality Advantage After Higher Court Ruling

The CTA denied reconsideration in a refund case after higher courts had already settled the taxpayer’s entitlement, leaving only the refundable amount. Taxpayers pursuing refunds or tax credits should treat favorable appellate rulings as decisive once they become final, because a later motion for reconsideration cannot reopen issues that higher courts have already settled. In […]

Mining Tax Refund Claims Need DENR-Approved Pre-Operating Expense Proof

Mining taxpayers must prove DENR-approved recoverable pre-operating expenses; audited financial statements alone failed to support the DST refund claim. Mining companies seeking a refund or tax credit for documentary stamp tax cannot rely on audited financial statements alone to prove that they remain within the recovery period under mining regulations. Where the taxpayer’s entitlement depends […]