DOJ Prosecutors May Use a Higher Screening Standard Before Filing Criminal Cases

The Supreme Court upheld the DOJโ€™s 2024 preliminary investigation rules, allowing prosecutors to require prima facie evidence with reasonable certainty of conviction. People facing criminal complaints before prosecutors may now invoke a more demanding screening standard at the preliminary investigation stage: the DOJโ€™s 2024 rules requiring prima facie evidence with reasonable certainty of conviction remain […]

When the Wrong Court Issues an Arrest Warrant, Detention Becomes a Constitutional Problem

A judge was fined for issuing an arrest warrant after the case moved to the RTC, highlighting remedies for defective warrants and unlawful detention. A person arrested under a warrant issued by a court that no longer has authority over the criminal case may challenge the detention immediately, and the judge who issued that warrant […]

A Desistance Affidavit Cannot End a Public Crime Without Prosecutorial Scrutiny

Affidavit of desistance cannot alone dismiss a public crime; the judge was fined for mishandling preliminary investigation records. Victims and heirs cannot privately erase a criminal case simply by signing an affidavit of desistance, especially when the offense charged is a public crime. In Padua v. Judge Molina, the Supreme Court made clear that judges […]

When a Judge Handles a Criminal Case Without Authority, the Case Can Go Off Track Before Trial Even Begins

A judge was fined for conducting an unauthorized preliminary investigation and proceeding without the prosecutor, reinforcing strict limits on criminal procedure. Criminal proceedings may be derailed when a judge takes procedural steps that the court has no authority to take, especially at the preliminary investigation and arraignment stages. For accused persons, complainants, and even taxpayers […]

When an Accused Loses the Right to Preliminary Investigation by Waiting Too Long

Preliminary investigation can be waived if not timely requested. The accused must act within the five-day Rule 112 period or trial may proceed. An accused person has a right to ask for preliminary investigation after an information is filed without one, but that right can be lost by inaction. The decisive rule is practical: the […]

When a Criminal Case Can Proceed Without a Preliminary Investigation

City court criminal cases may proceed after preliminary examination when full preliminary investigation is not required under the applicable rules. Accused persons in city or municipal court cases cannot automatically stop a criminal prosecution by insisting on a full preliminary investigation; where the applicable rules allow a preliminary examination to determine probable cause, the case […]

When a Criminal Complaint Goes Straight to Court: Why Forum Choice Can Decide the First Battle

A prior fiscal review does not always bar a court from conducting preliminary investigation when the complaint may be filed directly in court. A person accused in a criminal case cannot automatically defeat the proceeding merely because a similar complaint was first brought before a fiscal or prosecutor. Where the law allows direct filing in […]

When Local Courts May Still Investigate Libel Complaints Despite Special Venue Rules

Venue rules for libel complaints do not automatically remove a trial courtโ€™s authority to conduct preliminary investigation and determine probable cause. A person accused of libel cannot automatically stop a preliminary investigation merely because the complaint was filed in a Court of First Instance rather than before a city fiscal or local prosecutor. For lawyers, […]

When New Procedural Rules Overtake a Pending Criminal Challenge

A procedural attack on preliminary investigation may fail when later legal changes validate the challenged prosecutor authority and procedure. People challenging a prosecutorโ€™s authority in a pending criminal matter can lose the case when the very procedure they attack is later adopted as part of controlling law. In Litton v. Castillo, the Supreme Court treated […]