A tollway operator remained liable for real property tax because it had beneficial use, control, and toll revenue rights over government-owned infrastructure.
Private operators of government infrastructure cannot assume real property tax exemption merely because the underlying asset is owned by the Republic or used by the commuting public. Where a tollway operator has possession, control, and the right to collect toll revenues, local assessors may treat the operator as the taxable beneficial user of the property.
Background: A Toll Road Project Assessed for Real Property Tax
The dispute arose from the operation of the Southern Tagalog Arterial Road project under a toll concession structure. The Government, through the Department of Public Works and Highways, entered into a toll concession agreement with a private grantee for the operation and maintenance of the project over a 30-year concession period. The project was implemented through a Build-Transfer-and-Operate scheme under the BOT Law, and the grantee caused the creation of a single-purpose corporation to operate and maintain the tollway.
The local assessor issued a notice of assessment covering a property registered in the operatorās name and classified as commercial, with an assessed value of ā±108,984,560.00. The property was later declared delinquent for real property taxes for 2015 to 2016 in the amount of ā±5,449,228.00, followed by notices of delinquency, a warrant of levy, and steps toward auction. The operator opposed the assessment, arguing that the toll road formed part of a government project, that the Republic was the true owner, and that the property should be treated as property of public dominion exempt from real property tax (CTA EB No. 2943).
The Core Issue: Ownership Versus Beneficial Use
The operatorās principal theory was that real property owned by the Republic is exempt from real property tax under Section 234(a) of the Local Government Code. It argued that it did not own the toll road and that the public, not the operator, enjoyed the beneficial use of the property because motorists and commuters used the road.
The local government took the opposite view. It argued that the operator was a private corporation engaged in tollway operations for profit, that it had been assigned the rights and obligations necessary to operate the facility, and that no law, charter, concession agreement, or operations agreement expressly granted it an exemption from real property tax. The local government also emphasized that the operator controlled access to the tollway and generated revenue through the collection of toll fees.
The Court Sustained the Real Property Tax Assessment
The Court denied the operatorās petition for lack of merit and sustained the rulings of the assessment appeals bodies. The Court held that the operator had beneficial use of the subject property because it actually used, possessed, and enjoyed the property through the generation of toll revenues from public users. The fact that the facility served the public did not, by itself, remove the operator from real property tax liability.
The Court rejected the argument that motorists and commuters were the beneficial users contemplated by law. For real property tax purposes, the relevant taxable person was the private entity that had control over the property and derived income from it. The tollway was not open to the public in the same sense as an ordinary public road; access depended on payment of toll fees, and the operator could deny access to those unwilling to pay.
The Beneficial Use Principle in Local Taxation
Section 234(a) of the Local Government Code exempts real property owned by the Republic or its political subdivisions, except when the beneficial use has been granted, for consideration or otherwise, to a taxable person. This exception was decisive. The Court applied the principle that when government-owned property is placed in the possession and use of a taxable private entity, the tax burden shifts from the exempt owner to the taxable beneficial user.
The Court also emphasized that the beneficial use principle is not limited to simple leases or resale arrangements. In BOT-type arrangements, where a private proponent undertakes a project, assumes risks and costs, operates the facility for an agreed period, and earns revenues to recover costs and profits, the private operator may be treated as the actual, direct, and immediate user of the property.
No Express Tax Exemption Was Shown
The operator also failed because it could not point to any law, rule, regulation, or contractual provision expressly exempting it from real property tax. The Court reiterated the strict construction of tax exemptions: taxation is the rule, and exemption is the exception. A taxpayer claiming exemption must show that the exemption was granted in clear and unmistakable language.
The concession documents cited by the Court did not support exemption. Instead, they contemplated liability for taxes unless otherwise exempted. The toll concession agreement required the grantee, unless exempt, to pay all taxes due and collectible under Philippine tax laws. The operations and maintenance agreement likewise required the operator, unless exempt, to pay taxes due and collectible, and referred to the payment of monetary obligations incurred in implementing the agreement.
Why the Tax Declaration Could Be Issued in the Operatorās Name
The Court also upheld the issuance of the tax declaration in the operatorās name. Under Sections 204 and 205 of the Local Government Code, where real property owned by the Republic, its instrumentalities, or political subdivisions has been granted for beneficial use to a taxable person, the property may be listed, valued, and assessed in the name of the possessor or grantee.
Because the operator was found to have beneficial use of the tollway property, the local assessor correctly listed, valued, and assessed the property in the operatorās name. The Court therefore refused to cancel the tax declaration.
Practical Takeaways for Infrastructure Operators and Local Governments
This ruling matters to private proponents, tollway operators, public utility operators, infrastructure concessionaires, and local governments. A government-owned asset is not automatically shielded from real property tax once a private taxable entity is allowed to operate, control, and earn from it. The legal question is not simply who holds title, but who has beneficial use and who derives economic benefit from the property.
For private operators, the decision highlights the need to review concession agreements, operations agreements, and BOT project documents for tax allocation clauses. A clause requiring payment of taxes unless otherwise exempted may be used against the operator if it later claims immunity from local real property tax. Operators should also evaluate whether toll revenues, access control, maintenance obligations, and possession of facilities may be treated as indicia of beneficial use.
For CFOs and tax managers, the case is a reminder that real property tax exposure should be assessed at the bidding, concession negotiation, and project finance stages. The possible cost of local real property tax should be modeled as part of the projectās long-term economics, especially for infrastructure assets operated over multi-year concession periods.
For local governments, the decision reinforces the authority of assessors to look beyond formal ownership and examine beneficial use. However, assessments must still be properly documented, issued, and defended through the local assessment appeal process.
How Ablola, Saribong & Gueco Can Assist
Ablola, Saribong & Gueco advises taxpayers, infrastructure operators, property owners, and local governments on real property tax assessments, local tax disputes, and Court of Tax Appeals litigation. Our tax litigation practice can assist in reviewing assessments, preparing protests and appeals, evaluating tax exemption claims, and structuring defensible arguments on ownership, beneficial use, and local government taxing authority.
If your company is facing a real property tax assessment involving government-owned property, BOT projects, toll facilities, public utilities, or local tax delinquency proceedings, visit MakatiLawFirm.com to consult our tax litigation team.