When Illegal Government Allowances Need Not Be Refunded

Supreme Court upheld COAโ€™s COLA disallowance but excused refund due to finality, due process, lapse of time, and social justice under Madera. Government employees and local officials may still be spared from refunding disallowed benefits, even when the Commission on Audit correctly finds the payment illegal, if requiring repayment years later would be inequitable, prejudicial, […]

When Government Benefits Are Disallowed, Employees May Still Avoid Refunds

The Supreme Court upheld COAโ€™s COLA disallowance but excused officers and retired payees from refund due to good faith and undue prejudice. Government employees who receive disallowed benefits are not automatically protected by good faith, but the Supreme Court may still excuse repayment when refund would cause undue prejudice, especially where the payments were made […]