Supreme Court upheld COA’s COLA disallowance but excused refund due to finality, due process, lapse of time, and social justice under Madera.
Government employees and local officials may still be spared from refunding disallowed benefits, even when the Commission on Audit correctly finds the payment illegal, if requiring repayment years later would be inequitable, prejudicial, and contrary to social justice. The ruling matters to cities, agencies, accountants, approving officers, and rank-and-file government workers because it separates two questions that are often confused in audit cases: whether public funds were lawfully paid, and whether the people who received or approved them must personally return the money.
The Disallowance Was Valid, But Liability Was Not Automatic
The controversy arose from the City of Baguio’s release of cost of living allowance, or COLA, to city officials and employees for the period from January 1, 1990 to March 16, 1999. The Sangguniang Panlungsod had authorized the payment in 2008, relying on earlier Supreme Court cases that appeared to support claims for past COLA and similar benefits. COA later issued notices of disallowance, eventually covering a total of PHP 63,719,087.25, and held various approving, certifying, authorizing, and receiving parties liable.
In Magalong v. Commission on Audit (G.R. No. 263904), the Supreme Court agreed with COA on the central audit point: the payment of accrued COLA was not legally proper. Under the Salary Standardization Law, Republic Act No. 6758, allowances are generally deemed integrated into the standardized salary rates of government personnel unless expressly excluded by law or by a proper DBM issuance. COLA is not one of the statutory exclusions. It is a benefit meant to address increases in the cost of living, not an expense reimbursement tied to the performance of official duties.
The Court Reaffirmed the COLA Integration Doctrine
The Court applied what may be called the COLA Integration Doctrine: cost of living allowance for government personnel is generally deemed already included in standardized salaries under Section 12 of Republic Act No. 6758. The absence or invalidity of a DBM circular does not suspend the operation of the statute itself. The law is self-executing in declaring that allowances are integrated, subject only to the specific exclusions it names and to other exclusions properly determined by the DBM.
This is important for local governments and government-owned or controlled entities because many refund disputes trace back to the same mistaken assumption: that old cases involving DBM Corporate Compensation Circular No. 10 automatically revived a right to COLA from 1989 to 1999. The Supreme Court rejected that broad reading. Those cases did not create an open-ended authority for local government units to pay accrued COLA years after the fact, especially where the governing compensation law already treated the allowance as integrated into salary.
COA Could Not Reopen a Favorable Ruling Against Passive Recipients
The Supreme Court then turned to a separate due process issue. COA’s 2018 decision had already absolved the employees who were mere passive recipients, saying they did not need to refund the COLA they received. When the city officials moved for reconsideration, they challenged the liability of approving and certifying officers; they did not ask COA to reinstate liability against the rank-and-file payees. COA nevertheless later reversed itself and required passive recipients to return what they had received, invoking the Madera framework on disallowed benefits.
The Court held that this was improper. Once COA had favorably ruled on the passive recipients’ liability and no timely challenge was raised against that portion, the ruling became final as to them. COA could not, in resolving a motion filed by other parties on other issues, unilaterally revive the liability of employees who had no reason to appeal and no fair opportunity to defend themselves against a new theory of liability. This part of the ruling is especially significant for employees who receive a favorable COA disposition: finality and due process still matter in audit proceedings.
The Social Justice Exception Protected Both Employees and Officers
The most practical part of the decision is the Court’s application of Rule 2d of Madera. Under that rule, even when a notice of disallowance is upheld, the Court may excuse return of the amounts received based on undue prejudice, social justice considerations, and other bona fide exceptions. This is not a blanket amnesty. It is a case-by-case equitable exception for situations where strict refund would be unjust.
Here, the Court found sufficient grounds to excuse refund. COLA was meant to cushion increases in the cost of living. Seventeen years had passed since the employees received the amounts. Many recipients had likely spent the money on their families’ needs. Some original petitioners had died, while others had retired and no longer earned regular salaries. The amount involved, PHP 63,719,087.25, was not a small sum for ordinary government employees to shoulder. Requiring repayment after such a long time, in the Court’s view, would cause undue prejudice and defeat the ideal of social justice.
The Court extended the same protection to the approving, authorizing, and certifying officers. Although COA had found the payment improper, the officers did not act groundlessly; they relied on several Supreme Court rulings when the city authorized the release. The Court also reasoned that it would be inequitable to excuse the passive recipients while imposing a different civil burden on officers who were also recipients. To require only them to refund the amounts would create an unequal and unjust result.
What This Means for Local Governments, Accountants, and Employees
For local governments, the ruling is a warning against reviving old allowance claims based on isolated readings of past cases. Budget officers, accountants, and approving officials should treat compensation standardization rules as controlling and should verify whether a benefit is expressly excluded from salary integration before authorizing payment. Reliance on jurisprudence may support good faith in some circumstances, but it does not automatically make an unlawful benefit lawful.
For employees and public officers facing COA disallowances, the decision offers a more nuanced defense. The first battle is still legality: whether the benefit had a valid legal basis. But even if COA is correct on disallowance, the second battle is return: whether refund should be required under the Madera rules. Evidence of good faith, the purpose of the benefit, the lapse of time, retirement, death of recipients, economic hardship, and the practical use of the funds for family needs may all become relevant.
For private parties dealing with government offices, the case is also instructive. Public disbursement rules are strict, and government contracting or payment arrangements can later be reviewed through audit mechanisms. Businesses dealing with LGUs should ensure that payments, allowances, incentives, reimbursements, and special compensation arrangements rest on clear statutory, budgetary, and regulatory authority, not merely on institutional practice or a favorable interpretation of old cases.
How Ablola, Saribong & Gueco Can Help
Ablola, Saribong & Gueco advises public officers, local government units, contractors, employees, and private businesses dealing with government agencies on COA disallowances, audit liability, public funds compliance, administrative proceedings, and related civil litigation. If you are facing a notice of disallowance, a demand to refund benefits, or a dispute involving government payments, our litigation and regulatory practice can help assess the legality of the disbursement, available defenses under Madera, and the best procedural strategy before COA and the courts. Visit MakatiLawFirm.com to consult our team.