When Government Bonuses Must Be Returned: COA Disallowance, Special Trust Funds, and the Limits of Good Faith

Government employees may be required to refund unauthorized incentives after COA disallowance, even without fraud, when public funds lacked legal basis. Government employees who receive unauthorized bonuses or incentives may be ordered to return them even if they acted without fraud and believed the payment was valid. For state universities and other public institutions, the […]

When Government Benefits Are Disallowed, Good Faith Can Still Protect Employees from Refunds

COA may disallow unauthorized government benefits, but employees who received them in good faith may be protected from refund liability. Government employees who receive allowances or productivity awards later disallowed by audit authorities are not automatically required to return the money. If the payment was approved and received in good faith, and there is no […]

Water District Managers Can Keep Good-Faith Pay, But Future Salaries Must Follow the Salary Standardization Law

Water district managers remain covered by salary standardization, but good-faith recipients may avoid refunding COA-disallowed pay. Local water districts may fix the pay of their general managers, but that discretion stops at the Salary Standardization Law. The practical consequence is twofold: compensation above the lawful salary grade may be disallowed by the Commission on Audit, […]

State Universities Cannot Convert Academic Freedom Into Employee Allowance Authority

State universities cannot use academic freedom or fiscal powers to grant unauthorized allowances, but good-faith employee recipients may avoid refund. State universities and colleges may enjoy academic freedom and limited fiscal autonomy, but those powers do not automatically allow them to create employee allowances outside the Salary Standardization Law. The ruling teaches a practical rule […]

Subsequent Discrimination Doctrine: Equal Pay for BSP Employees

Equal protection bars selective salary exemptions when similarly situated BSP rank-and-file workers are left worse off than employees of other GFIs. The Subsequent Discrimination Doctrine protects employees when a law that was valid at enactment later becomes unconstitutional because later government action leaves similarly situated workers behind. For public-sector employees, the lesson is direct: compensation […]