When Government Recovers Shares, It Also Recovers the Dividends

Recovered corporate shares carry their dividends and fruits; true ownership may include cash, stock, and property dividends despite a narrow dispositive clause. A party declared to be the true owner of corporate shares is not limited to the paper certificates alone. Ownership carries the right to the fruits of the shares, including cash dividends, stock […]

A Corporation Cannot Keep Two Stock and Transfer Books: SEC Control Over Corporate Records Matters for Tax and Ownership Disputes

The Court upheld SEC authority to cancel a duplicate stock and transfer book, clarifying how corporate records affect ownership, authority, and tax-sensitive transactions. Corporate ownership records can decide who controls a company, who may act for it, and whose records tax and regulatory authorities may rely upon. In Provident International Resources Corporation v. Venus, the […]

Corporate Settlements Can End Litigation Even After Submission for Decision

The Supreme Court allowed withdrawal after settlement and denied intervention by a former counsel with only a contingent corporate interest. Corporate litigants who have resolved their boardroom dispute may ask the court to end the case even after it has been submitted for resolution, and a former lawyer or corporate officer cannot keep the lawsuit […]

PCGG Jurisdiction Limit: Corporate Acts Need Proper Standing

Corporate acts of a former sequestered company do not become Sandiganbayan cases without PCGG recovery issues, public funds, or standing. The PCGG Jurisdiction Limit Doctrine protects corporate decision-making from being converted into a Sandiganbayan case merely because the corporation once had a sequestration history. For stockholders, taxpayers, and concerned citizens, the practical lesson is direct: […]

When Shareholders Fight Over Property-for-Stock Deals, Courts Will Not Undo Corporate Capital by Rescission

Shareholders cannot use rescission to recover corporate assets when doing so would bypass capital, liquidation, and creditor-protection rules. Investors who contribute cash or property to a corporation for shares cannot easily unwind the deal by asking a court to return corporate assets, especially when the disputed transaction would disturb capital already treated as part of […]

When a Property Assignment Is Silent on Taxes, the Assignee May Have to Pay

Supreme Court held that a deed assigning land to a corporation can place tax and registration costs on the assignee despite a failed subscription deal. Parties who contribute land or property to a corporation cannot assume that taxes, transfer fees, and registration expenses will fall on the transferor merely because the property came from them. […]

Treasury Shares Do Not Erase Sequestration: What Disputed Corporate Stock Means for Dividends, Voting Rights, and Tax Planning

Disputed sequestered shares cannot simply be treated as treasury shares or stripped of dividends while ownership remains under court review. Corporate shares under government sequestration cannot be converted into treasury shares, stripped of voting rights, or relieved of dividend consequences merely because a company wants to restructure a disputed settlement. For business owners, investors, and […]

When a Court Order Hands Over Company Property Without a Hearing, It Can Be Voided

A corporate faction cannot use an emergency order to seize disputed company property without notice, hearing, and bond, though receivership may preserve assets. A party fighting over corporate control cannot be forced to surrender factories, buildings, machines, and corporate records through an emergency order that effectively decides possession before the opposing side is heard. The […]

When Corporate Papers Are Not Proof of Payment: Why Share Buyers Need Receipts and Stock Book Records

Corporate papers and officer titles do not prove share payment or ownership without competent evidence and stock book recording. A person who buys shares in a corporation cannot rely on board resolutions, secretary’s certificates, or an officer title alone to prove payment or ownership. The controlling lesson is practical and unforgiving: when money changes hands […]

When a Failed Disbarment Complaint Does Not Become a Damages Case

The Court held that a failed disbarment complaint does not create damages liability where the complainant had probable cause and the pleadings were relevant. A person who files a disbarment complaint, civil case, or other judicial proceeding does not automatically become liable for damages simply because the case fails. The controlling doctrine is that injury […]