When Share Sale Disputes Belong in Court, Not the SEC

A share sale dispute is not automatically an SEC case. Courts may hear contract rescission claims involving shares when ordinary civil law controls. Business owners who sell or buy controlling shares cannot automatically force every dispute into a specialized corporate forum simply by saying the case involves stock. When the real issue is the interpretation […]

Corporate Control Disputes Belong Before the Corporate Regulator, Not the Trial Court

Corporate control disputes cannot be disguised as ordinary rescission suits; jurisdiction follows the substance of the shareholder and management controversy. A lawsuit framed as rescission, damages, or injunction may still be an intra-corporate controversy when its real object is to recover control, management, board seats, or shareholder power in a corporation. For shareholders, banks, investors, […]

Lost Stock Certificates Are Not Ordinary Civil Claims: Why Stockholders Must Bring Replacement Disputes to the Corporate Forum

A stockholder’s claim for replacement of a missing stock certificate is an intra-corporate controversy, and damages do not move it to ordinary courts. Stockholders who are refused a replacement stock certificate cannot automatically turn that dispute into an ordinary damages case in the regular courts. When the controversy is fundamentally between a stockholder and the […]

When Shareholder Settlements Do Not Kill Corporate Fraud Claims

A shareholder settlement did not waive claims against non-settling directors, and courts may review stock issuances alleged to oppress minority shareholders. Corporate insiders cannot defeat a shareholder challenge simply by pointing to a partial settlement with other defendants or by calling a contested stock issuance a matter of internal management. Where the transaction allegedly injures […]