Taxpayers Get More Room to Challenge Collection When BIR Skips a Clear Final Decision

Taxpayers may challenge BIR collection after a warrant if no clear FDDA was issued, and the BIR cannot belatedly invoke the 10-year period without due process. Taxpayers facing BIR collection notices should not automatically assume that every preliminary collection letter starts the 30-day countdown to appeal. When the BIR fails to clearly issue a final […]

Taxpayers Challenging BIR Collection Measures Must Get Rule 65 Procedure Right

Certiorari petition dismissed after taxpayer failed to plead material dates, attach the challenged ruling, and show that alleged BIR inaction was proper for Rule 65. Taxpayers seeking to stop BIR collection measures through a petition for certiorari must first satisfy the strict procedural requirements of Rule 65, including pleading the material dates, attaching the ruling […]

Input VAT Claims Fail Without Complete Invoices and Court Evidence

A VAT taxpayer failed to prove input tax claims before the CTA; the compromise penalty was cancelled, but P74.75M in deficiency VAT and interest was upheld. Taxpayers facing deficiency VAT assessments cannot rely on explanations, reconciliations, or documents allegedly submitted during audit unless they can prove their claims with competent evidence before the Court of […]

BIR Cannot Reopen a Settled Audit Through a New LOA for the Same Taxable Period

A taxpayer defeated a P41.3M BIR assessment after the tax court voided a repeated audit, unauthorized officer action, prescription, and defective demand. Taxpayers who have already gone through a completed BIR audit, received final decisions, and paid the assessed amounts may challenge a later attempt to revive the same issue through another Letter of Authority, […]

Tax Crime Appeals Can Fail Without OSG Authority and Timely Filing

Criminal tax appeal dismissed: BIR lawyers lacked OSG authority, and the five-year period to prosecute a failure-to-pay-tax case had prescribed. Businesses and corporate officers facing criminal tax exposure should treat prescription and appeal authority as threshold defenses, not technical afterthoughts. A criminal tax case may be dismissed even before trial if the government files too […]

BIR Assessments Can Be Voided When the Taxpayer’s PAN Protest Is Ignored

BIR income tax and VAT assessments may be void where the taxpayer’s PAN reply is ignored and waivers extending prescription lack proper authority. Taxpayers facing deficiency income tax and VAT assessments should closely examine whether the BIR actually considered their reply to the Preliminary Assessment Notice before issuing the Formal Letter of Demand and Final […]

Defective BIR Waivers Can Void Tax Assessments When the Revenue Office Caused the Defects

A defective BIR waiver did not extend the tax assessment period where the revenue office caused the defects; late CTA filings also remain fatal. Taxpayers facing deficiency tax assessments should closely examine every waiver used by the BIR to extend the assessment period, because an invalid waiver may render the assessment prescribed even if the […]

Improper BIR Service Can Defeat Criminal Tax Charges

Improper service of BIR assessment notices led to acquittal in a criminal tax case, voiding the assessment and barring collection. Taxpayers facing criminal prosecution for alleged failure to pay deficiency taxes may still defeat the case if the government cannot prove that the underlying assessment was validly served and that the taxpayer knowingly refused to […]

BIR Collection Fails When Tax Assessments Are Void, Prescribed, or Still Under Appeal

The tax court cancelled a BIR assessment and collection warrant due to pending appeal, invalid LOA reassignment, prescription, and due process defects. Taxpayers facing BIR collection efforts should not assume that a warrant of distraint and levy automatically means the assessment is already final. When an assessment is still under administrative appeal, was issued after […]

BIR VAT Assessment Cut From P28.99 Million to P1.2 Million After Taxpayer Proves Valid Protest and Weak Third-Party Matching

A taxpayer reduced a P28.99M BIR VAT assessment to P1.2M after proving a valid protest and challenging weak third-party matching evidence. Taxpayers facing VAT assessments based on third-party matching, alleged undeclared sales, unsupported input taxes, or financial statement comparisons should not assume that a large BIR assessment is final merely because collection has already been […]