Taxpayer Cuts BIR Assessment From Php24.6 Million to Php3.12 Million After Challenging Deficiency Tax Findings

A shipyard taxpayer reduced a Php24.6M BIR assessment to Php3.12M after the Court cancelled unsupported FWT and compromise penalties. Taxpayers facing a multi-tax BIR assessment should not assume that every item in a Final Decision on Disputed Assessment is collectible: the Court may uphold only the portions supported by law and evidence, while cancelling unsupported […]

Invalid BIR Assessments: When Failure to Serve a PAN and Late Collection Defeat a Tax Case

A tax assessment was voided after the BIR failed to prove PAN service, improperly served the FAN, and began collection after prescription had expired. Taxpayers facing deficiency income tax or percentage tax assessments may challenge the assessment and collection itself when the Bureau of Internal Revenue fails to prove actual service of the Preliminary Assessment […]

Taxpayers Need Not Post a Billion-Peso Bond to Stop an Illegal Tax Collection

The Supreme Court held that the CTA may stop an illegal BIR collection without requiring a bond when the assessment or collection remedy is void. A taxpayer facing a disputed BIR assessment may ask the Court of Tax Appeals to stop collection without posting a cash deposit or surety bond when the assessment or the […]

Late BIR Appeal Locks In Cancellation of Deficiency Income Tax and VAT Assessments

A late BIR motion for reconsideration left the cancellation of deficiency income tax and VAT assessments final, executory, and beyond CTA review. Taxpayers who win before the Court of Tax Appeals should closely monitor post-decision deadlines, because a late motion for reconsideration can make a favorable tax judgment final, executory, and beyond further review by […]

Unsupported Zero-Rated Sales Can Still Trigger VAT Assessments When Export Service Proof Falls Short

A taxpayer failed to overturn a deficiency VAT assessment after unsupported zero-rated sales and prescription arguments were rejected by the tax court. Taxpayers claiming VAT zero-rating for services to foreign clients must prove, with clear and specific evidence, that the statutory requirements are met; otherwise, the BIR assessment may stand even if the disputed assessment […]

Criminal Tax Cases Can Fail When the Government Files Too Late or Contradicts Its Own Records

Criminal tax charge dismissed after the Court found prescription and rejected the prosecution’s later claim on the FAN receipt date. Taxpayers facing criminal tax charges may still secure dismissal when the government’s own assessment records show that the alleged offense has already prescribed, especially where the prosecution later attempts to revise a key date that […]

Taxpayers Can Cut BIR Assessments Based on Unverified Preprocessed Data

Taxpayer reduced a BIR assessment after unverified preprocessed data, prescribed VAT items, and compromise penalties were struck down, though income tax and VAT remained due. Taxpayers facing BIR assessments based on unverified third-party or preprocessed data should examine whether the alleged undeclared sales were actually confirmed, whether the assessment was issued within the prescriptive period, […]

BIR Garnishment Challenges Must Be Filed Within 30 Days, Tax Court En Banc Says

BIR garnishment and distraint challenges must be appealed within 30 days; letters to the BIR do not suspend the deadline for Court of Tax Appeals review. Taxpayers who receive a BIR warrant of distraint, levy, or garnishment must act quickly: a request for reconsideration or a letter asking the BIR to lift the warrant will […]

Invalid BIR Audit Authority Can Defeat Criminal Tax Charges for Willful Failure to Pay

A tax prosecution for willful failure to pay failed because the assessment was void, notice was unproven, and the Information was filed beyond the five-year period. Corporate officers facing criminal tax charges for alleged willful failure to pay taxes cannot be convicted merely because the BIR says an assessment became final. The prosecution must still […]

BIR Criminal Tax Case Dismissed After Five-Year Prescription Period Lapsed

Criminal tax charges for willful failure to pay deficiency income tax were dismissed after the government filed the Information beyond the five-year prescriptive period. Taxpayers facing criminal tax charges for alleged willful failure to pay deficiency taxes may invoke prescription before trial when the government files the Information beyond the five-year period counted from the […]