RMO No. 87-99: BIR No-Appeal Recommendations Must Reach the Commissioner Within 10 or 15 Days After Adverse Court Decisions

RMO No. 87-99 sets 10-day and 15-day BIR deadlines for no-appeal recommendations from adverse court decisions, affecting tax litigation strategy. BIR offices handling tax litigation must act quickly when they intend to recommend no further appeal from an adverse court decision: recommendations for cases handled by the National Office must reach the Office of the […]

When a Tax Refund Judgment Cannot Be Collected While an Appeal Is Pending

A refund winner cannot collect during appeal without exceptional reasons. A bond and trial court confidence in its ruling are not enough. A taxpayer who wins a refund case at the trial court does not automatically get to collect while the losing party appeals. Even when a tax-related exaction has been declared unconstitutional, execution pending […]

RMO No. 42-99: BIR Court Pleadings May Be Verified or Certified by the Deputy Commissioner When the Commissioner Is Absent

RMO No. 42-99 authorizes the Deputy Commissioner, Legal and Enforcement Group, to verify or certify BIR court pleadings when the Commissioner is absent. Businesses and tax litigants dealing with court cases involving the Bureau of Internal Revenue should take note that the authority to verify or certify BIR pleadings is not limited to the Commissioner […]

When Corporate Officers Cannot Reopen a Final Judgment by Claiming They Never Knew

Corporate officers cannot reopen a final judgment by claiming ignorance when service and appeal defects show they failed to protect their rights. Corporate directors, officers, and business owners cannot rely on alleged ignorance of a case to undo a final judgment when summons was validly served through counsel connected with the company and the party […]

When Court Seminars Affect Hearing Dates: What Litigants Should Know About Official-Time Court Training

Court personnel may attend official judicial training, but hearings should not be disrupted without advance notice to parties affected by cancellations. Court hearings may be reset when judges and court clerks are authorized to attend official judicial training, but the authorization is not a blank check to disrupt litigants. The governing consequence is practical: court […]

Tax Courts Cannot Rewrite Tax Policy: Why Jewelry Taxes Survived a Constitutional Challenge

The Supreme Court held that courts cannot invalidate jewelry taxes merely because they seem harsh or unwise; tax policy belongs to Congress. Businesses cannot defeat a tax law merely by showing that it is harsh, commercially inconvenient, or less competitive than tax policies in other countries. The controlling doctrine from this ruling is simple but […]

University Research Grants Are Not Automatically Taxable Service Income

Research grants to a non-profit university unit are not automatically taxable contractor income without proof of a commercial service business. Non-profit schools and their research units do not become taxable contractors merely because they receive sponsored research funding. Before the government can impose contractor’s tax, it must first prove a taxable business transaction: that the […]

Tax Amnesty Can Cancel Even Previously Assessed Deficiency Taxes

A valid tax amnesty can cancel even prior deficiency assessments when the law does not expressly exclude them, and BIR rules cannot add new exceptions. Taxpayers who validly avail of a tax amnesty may be relieved even from deficiency tax assessments already issued before the amnesty law, unless the amnesty measure itself expressly excludes those […]

Tax Refund Offset Doctrine: Why Deficiency Assessments Matter

Tax refunds may be denied or remanded when a deficiency assessment questions the same return supporting the taxpayer’s refund claim. The Tax Refund Offset Doctrine means a taxpayer cannot secure a tax refund while an unresolved deficiency assessment for the same taxable year casts doubt on the return supporting that refund. For businesses, especially banks […]

Reserve Deficiency Tax Rule: When Banks Must Pay Both Tax and Penalty

Banks may owe both BIR reserve deficiency tax and Central Bank penalties when each charge serves a distinct legal purpose. The reserve deficiency tax rule means that a bank may be required to pay both a regulatory penalty and a separate tax for the same reserve deficiency when each charge rests on a different law […]