Flexible Tariff Power Doctrine: When Tariff Hikes Are Valid

Presidential tariff hikes may be valid even if revenue-raising when Congress delegates power within constitutional and statutory limits. The Flexible Tariff Power Doctrine confirms that tariff and customs duties may validly serve both revenue and regulatory purposes, so long as the President acts within authority delegated by Congress and within the constitutional limits on tariff […]

A Tax Mistake Is Not Tax Fraud: When the BIR Cannot Impose the 50% Fraud Surcharge

A disclosed tax error is not fraud. The Supreme Court deleted the 50% surcharge because the taxpayer revealed the disputed remittance in his return. Taxpayers who disclose a questionable receipt in their income tax return are not automatically tax fraudsters, even if the amount is later found taxable. Fraud requires actual, intentional deception; an error, […]

Profit Remittance Costs Are Not Automatically Deductible Business Expenses

Profit remittance margin fees were not deductible taxes or business expenses because they related to post-income profit transfers, not Philippine income generation. Businesses cannot deduct every cost connected to moving profits out of the Philippines. A payment may feel commercially necessary, but for income tax purposes it must still be tied to the taxpayerโ€™s own […]

When a Government Agency Is Abolished, Its Debts Do Not Disappear

Abolishing a government agency does not erase lawful claims. Creditors may pursue successor-held assets, but only up to assets actually transferred. Creditors dealing with government corporations and regulatory agencies are not automatically defeated simply because the agency they dealt with is later abolished or reorganized. The controlling doctrine is that the dissolution or abolition of […]

Tax Amnesty Is Not a Shortcut Out of Criminal Tax Cases When the Disclosure Was Not Voluntary

Tax amnesty protects only taxpayers who strictly qualify; it cannot stop criminal tax cases when disclosure was not voluntary or already under investigation. Taxpayers cannot use a tax amnesty as a shield against criminal prosecution when the supposed disclosure was not voluntary, when the government already had the information through an informer or investigation, or […]

Foreign Companies Cannot Be Bound by Philippine Court Orders Through Shortcut Summons

Foreign companies with no Philippine presence cannot be bound by injunctions or damages through extraterritorial summons in personal actions, the Court held. Foreign corporations with no Philippine office, agent, property, or voluntary appearance cannot be forced to obey local injunctions or pay damages merely because a complaint was sent to them abroad. The doctrine is […]

Judgesโ€™ Salaries Are Taxable: Why Income Tax Is Not an Unconstitutional Salary Cut

Judgesโ€™ salaries are subject to income tax. Nitafan holds that withholding tax is not an unconstitutional decrease in judicial compensation. Judges and Justices cannot refuse withholding tax on the theory that income tax reduces their constitutionally protected salaries. The rule from Nitafan is clear: the constitutional ban against decreasing judicial compensation protects the salary rate […]

A Tax Can Regulate an Industry and Still Be Valid

The Supreme Court upheld a videogram industry tax, ruling that a levy may raise revenue and regulate business when tied to a valid public purpose. A Philippine tax is not invalid simply because it also regulates behavior, discourages certain businesses, or protects another industry. When Congress or the lawmaking authority imposes a levy for a […]

BOAC Source-of-Income Rule: Philippine Ticket Sales Are Taxable

Foreign corporations may owe Philippine income tax on local ticket sales when Philippine agents produce the income, even if final services occur abroad. The BOAC Source-of-Income Rule warns foreign corporations that Philippine tax exposure may arise even when the actual travel, delivery, or performance occurs abroad, if the income-producing commercial activity is carried on in […]