Tax Raids Need Judicial Scrutiny: Why BIR Search Warrants Cannot Be Fishing Expeditions

Tax search warrants must name one specific offense, be personally examined by a judge, and clearly identify records to be seized. Businesses facing tax investigations are not stripped of constitutional protection merely because the government suspects unpaid taxes. In Bache & Co., the Supreme Court made clear that a tax search warrant must be issued […]

When a Levy Is Not a Tax: Sugar Centrals Cannot Refuse a Statutory Industry Charge Because They Dislike How the Fund Is Spent

Sugar centrals must pay the PHILSUGIN levy despite alleged fund misuse; the remedy is to challenge unauthorized spending, not refuse payment. Businesses required to contribute to a statutory industry fund cannot simply stop paying because they believe the government agency is misusing the money. When the charge is imposed as part of the State’s police […]

When Officer Compensation Becomes a Disallowed Tax Deduction

Officer pay to controlling shareholders is deductible only if tied to real services and reasonable in amount; excessive payments may be treated as profit distributions. Corporations cannot automatically deduct large payments to controlling officers merely by calling them salaries, bonuses, commissions, or supervision fees. For income tax purposes, compensation must still pass a reasonableness test: […]

When the Taxpayer Files No Return, the Government Has Ten Years to Sue

Failure to file an income tax return allows the Government to sue for collection within ten years from discovery, defeating a three-year prescription defense. A taxpayer who fails to file an income tax return cannot rely on the ordinary three-year assessment period to defeat collection. In tax cases involving omission of returns, the Government may […]

Pasay Property Owners Can Face Finance Review After Winning a Tax Assessment Appeal

A Pasay property tax appeal win may still be reviewed by the Secretary of Finance when the city charter preserves administrative review authority. A Pasay property owner who wins before the City Board of Tax Appeals may still face administrative review by the Secretary of Finance before the assessment fight is truly over. The ruling […]