Businesses may recover excise taxes paid under protest when the BIR applies higher tax rates before proper publication or relies on invalid issuances.

Taxpayers facing tax refund disputes should treat this ruling as a reminder that the government cannot collect higher internal revenue taxes before the law imposing them has properly taken effect, and that courts may invalidate revenue issuances when they go beyond the statute they supposedly implement. For manufacturers, importers, and other businesses subject to excise taxes, the decision is especially important: a payment made under protest, even through tax credit certificates, may still be recoverable when the Bureau of Internal Revenue applies the wrong rate or relies on an invalid effectivity date.

Background: The Excise Tax Dispute

The dispute arose from excise taxes on fermented liquor products withdrawn from breweries during the period from January 23, 2020 to February 9, 2020. The taxpayer, a domestic corporation engaged in the manufacture, sale, and distribution of fermented and malt-based beverages, paid excise taxes under protest after the Commissioner took the position that higher rates under Republic Act No. 11467 had already become effective before February 10, 2020.

The controversy had two components. First, the taxpayer sought a refund of Php8,278,851.12, representing the alleged excess excise tax caused by the use of a Php27.07 per liter rate instead of the taxpayer’s asserted correct rate of Php26.44 per liter. Second, the taxpayer sought a refund of Php1,060,496,977.92, representing excise taxes paid under protest after the BIR assessed additional excise taxes based on the supposed earlier effectivity of Republic Act No. 11467. The Court in Division granted the full refund, and the Commissioner elevated the case to the Court En Banc (CTA EB No. 3157).

The Commissioner’s Main Arguments

The Commissioner challenged the refund on jurisdictional and substantive grounds. The government argued that the tax court should not have entertained the taxpayer’s challenge to the validity of revenue regulations and memorandum circulars, particularly Revenue Regulations No. 17-2012, Revenue Memorandum Circular No. 90-2012, Revenue Memorandum Circular No. 65-2020, and Revenue Memorandum Circular No. 113-2020. The Commissioner also maintained that Republic Act No. 11467 became effective on January 23, 2020 because it was allegedly published through the Official Gazette website.

The taxpayer countered that the case was fundamentally a refund case for unlawfully collected excise taxes. The challenge to the BIR issuances was not an improper collateral attack, but a necessary incident of determining whether the collection had legal basis. The taxpayer also argued that the increased excise tax under Republic Act No. 11467 could apply only upon proper publication in the printed Official Gazette or in a newspaper of general circulation.

The Court’s Ruling: The Refund Was Properly Granted

The Court En Banc denied the Commissioner’s petition and affirmed the refund of Php1,068,775,829.04. The ruling sustained the Court in Division’s conclusion that the taxpayer proved its entitlement to recover excise taxes erroneously, excessively, illegally, or wrongfully collected for the period involved.

On jurisdiction, the Court held that the tax court may pass upon the validity or constitutionality of tax laws, regulations, and administrative issuances when the issue is raised in a tax assessment or refund case. The Court relied on jurisprudence recognizing that the determination of the validity of revenue orders, memorandum circulars, rulings, and similar issuances falls within the tax court’s authority when such determination is necessary to resolve a tax dispute.

The Court also rejected the argument that the taxpayer was required to exhaust administrative remedies before questioning the issuances. Because the assailed issuances were issued in the exercise of quasi-legislative or rule-making power, the doctrine of exhaustion of administrative remedies did not bar the taxpayer from seeking judicial relief.

Revenue Issuances Cannot Create a Tax Rate Beyond the Law

A major portion of the decision dealt with the validity of the BIR’s use of the Php20.57 initial rate under Revenue Memorandum Circular No. 90-2012 as the basis for later indexation. The Court emphasized that administrative issuances may fill in the details of a statute, but they cannot override, supplant, or amend the law itself.

The Court affirmed the finding that the applicable statutory framework under Republic Act No. 10351 did not support the continued use of the higher pre-existing rate in the manner adopted by the BIR issuance. The decision explained that the so-called no downgrading approach, as applied through the issuances, conflicted with the statutory classification system for fermented liquors. Because the law required classification based on net retail price and corresponding tax rates, the BIR could not use an administrative circular to impose a rate not supported by the statute.

The Court further noted that Revenue Memorandum Circular No. 90-2012 was void not only because it went beyond the law, but also because it was issued without the required prior notice and hearing despite substantially increasing the burden on affected taxpayers. For the taxpayer’s beer products, the Court sustained the finding that the correct excise tax rate for 2020, after applying indexation, was Php26.44 per liter rather than Php27.07 per liter. The resulting Php0.63 per liter difference supported the refund of Php8,278,851.12.

Higher Excise Taxes Under the New Law Applied Only After Proper Publication

The Court also ruled that Republic Act No. 11467 became effective only on February 10, 2020, when it was published in print in the Official Gazette. The Commissioner’s reliance on online publication through the Official Gazette website did not persuade the Court.

The decision applied the principle that publication is a due process requirement. Taxpayers cannot be burdened with new or higher taxes before they have proper notice that the law has taken effect. The Court reasoned that retroactively applying the increased excise tax rates to transactions before proper publication would impose new liabilities on taxpayers who had relied in good faith on the tax laws then in force.

Because the higher Php35.00 per liter rate under Republic Act No. 11467 could be imposed only beginning February 10, 2020, the BIR’s attempt to collect the increased rate for removals made from January 23, 2020 to February 9, 2020 was erroneous. Revenue Memorandum Circular No. 65-2020 and Revenue Memorandum Circular No. 113-2020 were therefore null and void insofar as they declared earlier effectivity dates for the amendatory law.

Why This Matters for Taxpayers and Importers

The decision is significant beyond the fermented liquor industry. It reinforces several principles that matter in BIR assessments, excise tax disputes, customs-related tax exposure, and refund litigation. First, a taxpayer may recover amounts paid under protest when the collection is based on an invalid regulation, an erroneous circular, or a premature application of a tax law. Second, the BIR cannot use administrative issuances to legislate new burdens or expand the scope of a statute. Third, proper publication remains central to due process, especially when a law increases tax liability.

For CFOs and tax managers, the practical takeaway is straightforward: do not assume that a BIR assessment is valid merely because it relies on a regulation, circular, or internal position. The legal basis, statutory authority, effectivity date, and procedural validity of the issuance should be tested. Businesses should also preserve proof of payment, protest letters, tax debit memos, filing references, and supporting schedules because refund claims are won or lost on evidence.

Practical Steps After an Erroneous Excise Tax Collection

A taxpayer that believes it paid an excessive excise tax should immediately review the legal basis for the rate imposed, determine whether the governing law had already taken effect, and check whether the BIR issuance relied upon is consistent with the statute. Where payment has already been made, the taxpayer must evaluate the deadlines for administrative and judicial refund claims and prepare documentary evidence as if the case will be litigated.

This ruling also underscores the importance of framing the case correctly. A refund claim may require the court to determine the validity of a revenue issuance, but the taxpayer must still prove the payment, the legal error, the amount refundable, and compliance with procedural requirements. In high-value tax disputes, early litigation planning can make the difference between a recoverable claim and a lost refund opportunity.

How Ablola, Saribong & Gueco Can Assist

Ablola, Saribong & Gueco assists taxpayers, importers, manufacturers, and corporate groups in BIR assessments, excise tax disputes, refund claims, tax credit certificate issues, and Court of Tax Appeals litigation. Our tax litigation practice can evaluate whether a BIR assessment or collection rests on a valid legal basis, prepare administrative protests and refund claims, build the evidentiary record, and represent clients before the Court of Tax Appeals.

If your business has paid taxes under protest, received a deficiency tax assessment, or faces a dispute involving the effectivity or validity of a tax regulation or memorandum circular, visit MakatiLawFirm.com to consult our tax litigation team.


Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *