RMC No. 88-2012 clarifies tax on employee stock option gains, including compensation tax, fringe benefit tax, DST, CGT, and stock transaction tax.
Employers granting stock options to employees must treat the employee’s gain upon exercise as taxable compensation or, for qualifying managerial and supervisory employees, as a taxable fringe benefit, with the taxable amount measured by the excess of the book value or fair market value of the shares, whichever is higher, over the fixed exercise price. This matters immediately for companies using stock option plans as part of compensation, because the tax treatment applies whether the shares involved are issued by a domestic corporation or a foreign corporation.
What Changed Under RMC No. 88-2012
RMC No. 88-2012 clarifies the Philippine tax treatment of income or gain derived by employees from the exercise of stock option plans. The clarification is important because stock options are often used as part of executive compensation, employee retention packages, performance incentives, or long-term reward programs. The issuance confirms that the tax consequences arise at the point when the employee exercises the option and obtains shares at a price lower than the relevant value of the shares at that time.
The circular refers to a prior ruling involving stock options granted by domestic corporations as part of a compensation plan. Under that plan, employees were given the right to buy a specified number of shares of a foreign corporation within a specified time or period from the grant date, at a fixed price regardless of the future market price of the stock. The plan was designed to reward employees based on performance, outstanding business achievements, and exemplary organizational, technical, or business accomplishments. It also covered certain employees who received a one-time number of shares upon employment.
Tax Treatment Upon Exercise of the Stock Option
The key rule is that any income or gain derived by employees from the exercise of stock options is treated as additional compensation subject to income tax and, consequently, to withholding tax on compensation. This applies where the stock option benefit is part of the employee’s compensation arrangement.
However, where the stock option plan is granted to managerial or supervisory employees and qualifies as a fringe benefit, the income or gain is subject to fringe benefit tax under Section 33 of the National Internal Revenue Code of 1997, as amended. For employers, the practical point is that the classification of the employee and the nature of the benefit must be reviewed before payroll, withholding, and tax reporting treatment is finalized.
The taxable amount is the difference between the book value or fair market value of the shares, whichever is higher, at the time of exercise of the stock option, and the price fixed on the grant date. In simple terms, if the employee is allowed to acquire shares at a fixed grant-date price and the shares are worth more at exercise, the spread is taxable. The circular expressly states that the option has value only if, at the time of exercise, the stock is worth more than the price fixed on the grant date.
Who Is Affected
RMC No. 88-2012 affects employers that grant stock options as part of compensation, incentive, retention, or reward plans. This includes Philippine corporations granting stock option benefits to employees, Philippine subsidiaries participating in regional or global equity incentive plans, and companies whose employees receive options over shares of a foreign corporation.
The issuance also affects employees who exercise stock options, especially where the exercise price is lower than the book value or fair market value of the shares at the time of exercise. Rank-and-file employees may be subject to income tax and withholding tax on compensation, while managerial and supervisory employees may fall under the fringe benefit tax regime if the benefit qualifies as a fringe benefit under Section 33 of the Tax Code.
Documentary Stamp Tax on Original Issuance of Shares
If the shares to be issued upon exercise of the stock options come from the unissued shares of stock of the issuing corporation, the original issuance of those shares is subject to documentary stamp tax under Section 174 of the National Internal Revenue Code, as amended. Companies implementing employee stock option plans must therefore confirm whether the shares are newly issued shares or existing shares, because the DST consequence applies to the original issuance of shares from unissued capital stock.
This is a significant compliance point for corporate secretaries, finance teams, and tax departments. A stock option plan should not be reviewed only from the standpoint of compensation tax. The corporate act of issuing shares, and the documents evidencing issuance or transfer, may also trigger documentary stamp tax obligations.
Tax Treatment When Employees Later Sell the Shares
RMC No. 88-2012 also clarifies the tax consequences when employees later sell, barter, exchange, or otherwise dispose of shares acquired through the exercise of stock options. The tax treatment depends on the type of shares involved.
If the shares are shares of stock in a domestic corporation not traded in the stock exchange, any gain is subject to capital gains tax under Sections 24 and 25 of the National Internal Revenue Code, as amended. For this purpose, the gain from the sale or transfer is the difference between the selling price, book value, or fair market value of the shares, whichever is higher, at the date of sale, and the price at the time of exercise of the option.
The sale or transfer of shares of a domestic corporation not traded in the stock exchange is also subject to documentary stamp tax under Section 175 of the National Internal Revenue Code, as amended, as implemented by Revenue Regulations No. 13-2004. The DST applies upon execution of the deed transferring ownership or rights, or upon delivery, assignment, or indorsement of the shares in favor of another person.
If the shares are listed and traded through the Local Stock Exchange, the transaction is subject to stock transaction tax under Section 127(A) of the National Internal Revenue Code, as amended. If the shares involved are shares of stock in a foreign corporation, any gain is subject to ordinary income tax.
Effective Date and Revocation of Inconsistent Issuances
RMC No. 88-2012 takes effect immediately. The circular also states that all other issuances, including rulings inconsistent with it, are revoked or modified accordingly. Businesses that previously relied on a different interpretation of stock option taxation should therefore review their existing plans, payroll tax treatment, and documentation.
Practical Steps for Employers and Finance Teams
Employers with stock option plans should first identify all stock option grants, the employees covered, the grant date, the fixed exercise price, the exercise date, and the book value or fair market value of the shares at the time of exercise. These details are necessary to compute the taxable compensation or taxable fringe benefit.
Second, companies should classify the employees receiving the benefit. If the recipient is a rank-and-file employee, the taxable gain will generally be treated as additional compensation subject to income tax and withholding tax on compensation. If the recipient is a managerial or supervisory employee and the benefit qualifies as a fringe benefit, the company must evaluate the fringe benefit tax consequences under Section 33 of the Tax Code.
Third, companies should determine whether the shares are shares of a domestic corporation or a foreign corporation, and whether the shares are newly issued, unlisted domestic shares, listed domestic shares, or foreign shares. This classification affects DST, capital gains tax, stock transaction tax, and ordinary income tax treatment upon later disposition.
Finally, employers should ensure that stock option documents, board approvals, payroll records, tax computations, and withholding reports are consistent. For businesses using regional or global stock option plans, Philippine tax review should be performed before exercise events occur, not merely after employees have already received or sold the shares.
How Ablola, Saribong & Gueco Can Help
Stock option plans can create overlapping issues in compensation tax, fringe benefit tax, documentary stamp tax, capital gains tax, and corporate documentation. Ablola, Saribong & Gueco assists employers, executives, finance teams, and in-house counsel in reviewing employee incentive plans, determining the correct BIR tax treatment, preparing compliance documentation, and managing tax risks arising from equity-based compensation.
For legal and tax guidance on stock option plans, employee compensation structures, fringe benefit tax, and BIR compliance, contact Ablola, Saribong & Gueco through MakatiLawFirm.com.