RMC No. 89-2012 clarifies VAT, income, receipt, and deduction rules for client deposits and advances paid to professional partnerships.
General professional partnerships must treat client deposits and advances for necessary expenses as part of the firm’s gross receipts or unearned income, issue official receipts upon receipt, and record the corresponding VAT treatment where applicable. For law firms, accounting firms, and similar professional partnerships, the key compliance risk is that the same third-party expense must not be deducted twice: once by the firm and again by the client.
What RMC No. 89-2012 Changed
RMC No. 89-2012 clarified the income tax, VAT, invoicing, and bookkeeping treatment of amounts deposited or advanced by clients to general professional partnerships for necessary expenses. The issuance addresses a common professional-services arrangement where a client gives a law firm, accounting firm, or similar professional partnership a sum of money to cover filing fees, travel expenses, representation expenses, courier charges, documentation expenses, or other expenses necessary to perform the engagement.
The clarification matters because receipts or invoices issued by third-party establishments for these expenses are often issued in the name of the professional firm, not the client. Without clear rules, both the firm and the client may attempt to claim the same expense as a deduction from gross income. RMC No. 89-2012 prevents that result by assigning the expense deduction to the party in whose name the official receipt or invoice is issued and by requiring proper recognition of the client’s payment to the firm.
Who Is Affected
The ruling directly affects general professional partnerships, including accounting firms, law firms, and other professional firms that receive cash deposits or advances from clients to pay expenses on the client’s behalf. It also affects clients of those firms, especially corporate taxpayers, SMEs, withholding agents, and VAT-registered businesses that rely on official receipts and invoices to support deductions and input VAT claims.
For CFOs and accountants, the practical issue is not only whether the expense was actually incurred, but whose official receipt or invoice supports the deduction. If the third-party receipt or invoice is issued in the name of the professional firm, the firm records the expense in its books and may claim it as a deduction from gross income. The client may not claim that same third-party expense as its own deduction. Instead, the client’s deductible item is the payment to the professional firm, supported by the official receipt issued by the firm.
Service Income and VAT Treatment of Deposits and Advances
When the professional firm receives cash deposits or advances from the client, the firm must issue a corresponding official receipt. The amount received is booked as income of the firm, forms part of the firm’s gross receipts, and is subject to value-added tax, if applicable.
The accounting treatment depends on the firm’s accounting method. If the firm uses cash-basis accounting, the deposit or advance is treated and recorded as service income upon receipt. If the firm uses accrual-basis accounting, the deposit or advance is booked as unearned income or a liability, specifically as deposits from clients, with the applicable output VAT recorded. This distinction is important for professional firms that maintain accrual books but receive client funds before the expenses are fully incurred or liquidated.
Deduction Rules for Expenses Paid on Behalf of Clients
RMC No. 89-2012 states that the professional firm must record the expenses it incurred and paid on behalf of the client as its own expenses for income tax purposes if the official receipt or invoice issued by the third-party establishment is in the name of the firm. Accordingly, those expenses, supported by official receipts or invoices in the name of the firm, may be claimed by the firm as deductions from its gross income.
The client, on the other hand, may not claim those same third-party expenses as deductions from its own gross income. The client’s deductible expense is its payment to the professional firm as professional fees, provided the payment is duly substantiated by official receipts issued by the firm pursuant to Section 34(A)(1) of the Tax Code.
The circular also makes clear that the professional firm and the client are not precluded from availing of the Optional Standard Deduction, or OSD, when allowed under existing tax laws, rules, and regulations. This is relevant for taxpayers choosing between itemized deductions and OSD, because the circular clarifies the proper characterization of expenses but does not remove the availability of OSD where otherwise permitted.
Required Recording When the Client Makes a Deposit for Expenses
When the client makes a deposit for necessary expenses, the professional firm issues an official receipt and records the receipt based on its accounting method. Under cash accounting, the firm records cash, service income, and output VAT. Under accrual accounting, the firm records cash, deposits from clients, and output VAT.
The client’s books must mirror the proper treatment. If the client uses cash-basis accounting, the client treats the deposit or advance as an outright expense, recording professional fees and input VAT against cash. If the client uses accrual-basis accounting, the client treats the amount as a deferred expense or prepayment, recording deposits to professional firms and input VAT against cash.
When the deposit is later used for third-party expenses and the official receipt or invoice is issued in the firm’s name, the firm records expenses, input VAT, and cash. Under accrual accounting, the firm also transfers the related amount from deposits from clients to service income. If the deposit is insufficient and the firm advances additional amounts for the client, the firm records a receivable from the client and service income.
Liquidation of Deposits and Return of Excess Amounts
Upon liquidation of the deposit and expenses, the professional firm must make a summary computation of all expenses incurred. If the client’s deposit exceeds the total expenses and the excess is returned to the client, the firm records the liquidation as a return of the excess. The entries shown in the circular reflect reductions to service income and the related VAT treatment, with cash credited for the amount returned.
For the client, receipt of the excess deposit must also be recorded. Under cash accounting, the client records cash and reverses the corresponding professional fees and output VAT. Under accrual accounting, the client adjusts professional fees, cash, deposits to professional firms, and output VAT. The practical takeaway is that deposits should not be left unliquidated or unsupported. The firm must prepare a summary computation, and both firm and client should align their books with the liquidation.
Treatment When the Firm Advances Expenses Without a Prior Deposit
RMC No. 89-2012 also covers the situation where the client does not make a prior deposit and the professional firm advances the necessary expenses on the client’s behalf. When the firm pays third-party establishments and the official receipt or invoice is in the name of the firm, the firm records the expenses, input VAT, and cash. If the firm uses accrual accounting, it also records accounts receivable from clients and service income.
After advancing the expenses, the firm must prepare a summary computation of all expenses made on behalf of the client and bill the client for the same. Upon receipt of the amount billed, the firm must issue an official receipt. Under cash accounting, the firm records cash, service income, and output VAT. Under accrual accounting, the firm records cash against accounts receivable from clients and output VAT. The client records the payment as professional fees and input VAT against cash, whether it uses cash or accrual accounting.
Deadlines, Effectivity, and Penalties
RMC No. 89-2012 states that it takes effect immediately. It does not prescribe a special fixed deadline for past liquidation or a separate penalty table specific to these deposits and advances. However, the compliance obligation is immediate for covered transactions because professional firms must issue official receipts, recognize gross receipts or unearned income as applicable, account for VAT where applicable, prepare expense liquidation summaries, and prevent duplicate deduction of expenses.
The circular’s main compliance risk is improper deduction and improper substantiation. If both firm and client claim the same third-party expense, the deduction would be contrary to the Tax Code. Businesses should expect that the BIR may review the official receipts, invoices, VAT entries, and expense liquidation schedules to determine whether the claimed deductions and input VAT are properly supported.
Practical Compliance Steps for Firms and Clients
Professional firms should update their billing, cashiering, and accounting procedures so that every client deposit or advance is covered by an official receipt upon receipt. The firm should identify whether it uses cash or accrual accounting, then record the amount as service income or deposits from clients, with output VAT where applicable. It should also ensure that third-party receipts and invoices issued in the firm’s name are recorded in the firm’s books and not passed to the client as the client’s own deductible third-party expenses.
Clients should review how they record advances to law firms, accounting firms, and other general professional partnerships. Where the third-party receipts are in the name of the firm, the client should not claim those third-party expenses directly. Instead, the client should claim the payment to the firm as professional fees, supported by the firm’s official receipt, and should coordinate with the firm for proper liquidation of deposits, refunds of excess amounts, and billing of additional amounts.
Both sides should maintain a clear audit trail: the official receipt issued by the professional firm for the deposit or reimbursement, the third-party receipts and invoices issued in the firm’s name, the summary computation of expenses incurred, the liquidation of excess deposits or billing of deficiencies, and the VAT entries recorded by each party. This is especially important for VAT-registered taxpayers claiming input VAT and for businesses using itemized deductions rather than the Optional Standard Deduction.
How Ablola, Saribong & Gueco Can Help
RMC No. 89-2012 is particularly relevant to professional firms, corporate clients, and finance teams that regularly deal with retainers, deposits, reimbursable expenses, advances, and liquidation reports. Ablola, Saribong & Gueco assists businesses in reviewing billing templates, official receipt practices, VAT treatment, expense substantiation, and BIR audit exposure involving professional fees and client reimbursements.
For assistance in aligning your contracts, billing practices, and accounting documentation with BIR rules on deposits, advances, professional fees, VAT, and deductible expenses, contact Ablola, Saribong & Gueco through MakatiLawFirm.com.