A corporate title or stock ownership does not automatically make dismissal disputes intra-corporate; regular employee-officers may sue before the Labor Arbiter.

Company officers are not automatically pushed into corporate litigation when they lose their jobs. If the position is not a true corporate office created by the by-laws and filled by board or stockholder election, an illegal dismissal complaint remains a labor case before the Labor Arbiter.

Why This Case Matters to Employees and Business Owners

The ruling in Cosare v. Broadcom Asia clarifies a practical and often misunderstood boundary between labor law and corporate law. Many companies give employees impressive titles such as assistant vice president, vice president for sales, director, head, manager, or officer. But a title alone does not determine where a dismissal case should be filed. For jurisdictional purposes, the law asks a more specific question: was the employee a corporate officer in the legal sense, or merely a regular employee holding a managerial or officer-level position?

This distinction matters because the wrong forum can delay relief for years. If the dispute is truly intra-corporate, the case belongs to the Regional Trial Court exercising special commercial jurisdiction. If the dispute is really about termination of employment, unpaid wages, suspension, backwages, separation pay, or damages arising from an employer-employee relationship, the Labor Arbiter generally has jurisdiction.

Background: A Sales Executive, a Stockholder, and a Dismissal Dispute

Raul C. Cosare had worked in the broadcast equipment business connected with Dante Arevalo and later Broadcom Asia, Inc. He became an incorporator and stockholder of Broadcom, holding 100 shares, and was later promoted to Assistant Vice President for Sales and Head of Technical Coordination. He claimed a monthly salary and commissions and reported to company superiors in the ordinary course of employment.

After Cosare sent a confidential memorandum to Arevalo accusing another company executive of irregularities, the dispute escalated. Cosare alleged that he was asked to resign in exchange for financial assistance, charged with misconduct and breach of trust, denied access to company files and assets, prevented from entering the office, and later accused of abandonment. He filed a labor complaint for constructive dismissal, illegal suspension, and monetary claims. The case reached the Supreme Court as Cosare v. Broadcom Asia, Inc. (G.R. No. 201298, February 5, 2014).

The Doctrine: Not Every Officer Is a Corporate Officer

The Supreme Court held that the Labor Arbiter, not the regular courts, had jurisdiction over Cosare’s complaint. The controlling doctrine is that a corporate title does not, by itself, convert an illegal dismissal case into an intra-corporate controversy. A person is considered a corporate officer only when two requirements concur: first, the office must be created by the corporation’s charter or by-laws; and second, the officer must be elected or appointed by the directors or stockholders in the manner contemplated by corporate law.

Broadcom argued that Cosare was a stockholder and an officer, and that its by-laws allowed the board to appoint other officers as necessary. The Court rejected this as insufficient. The by-laws specifically identified the president, vice-president, treasurer, and secretary. The company did not prove that the Assistant Vice President for Sales position was itself created as a corporate office under the by-laws or that Cosare was elected or appointed to that office by the board or stockholders. General Information Sheets identifying him as an officer did not control the legal character of his position.

The Court also stressed that stock ownership does not automatically make every dispute with the corporation intra-corporate. The court must examine both the relationship of the parties and the nature of the controversy. Here, the controversy centered on Cosare’s rights as an employee: whether he was constructively dismissed, whether his suspension was lawful, and whether he was entitled to labor remedies. Those questions would exist even if he were not a stockholder. The stockholder relationship was incidental, not controlling.

Constructive Dismissal: When Work Becomes Impossible or Unreasonable

The Court also affirmed the finding of constructive dismissal. Constructive dismissal occurs when continued employment is rendered impossible, unreasonable, or unlikely, including situations where the employer’s discrimination, insensibility, or disdain becomes unbearable and leaves the employee with no real choice but to leave.

Cosare was not merely served a notice to explain. The surrounding facts showed that the company had effectively rejected his continued employment. He was allegedly asked to resign before the disciplinary process was completed. He was suspended from access to company files, records, and assets. He was barred from entering the company premises. His attempt to submit an explanation was refused for being beyond the company’s 48-hour deadline. The Court viewed these acts as inconsistent with a genuine intent to investigate fairly before deciding his employment status.

The ruling is also important on procedural due process. The Court cited the rule that an employee must be given a reasonable opportunity to answer charges. A mere 48-hour period was inadequate when the employee needed time to study the accusations, consult counsel or a representative, gather evidence, and prepare a defense. The first notice must also contain a detailed narration of the facts and the specific grounds or company rules allegedly violated.

Why the Abandonment Defense Failed

The employer’s abandonment defense also failed. Abandonment requires both failure to report for work without valid reason and a clear intention to sever the employment relationship. The Court found those elements absent. Cosare’s absence was not voluntary because he had been denied access to company assets and, according to the findings, barred from entering the workplace. It was illogical for the employer to prevent an employee from working and then accuse him of abandoning work.

This aspect of the ruling is highly practical. Employers cannot manufacture abandonment by locking an employee out, cutting off access, or making work impossible, then treating the employee’s non-reporting as resignation. For employees, the ruling confirms that reporting incidents, documenting lockouts, and promptly filing appropriate labor claims may defeat a later abandonment narrative.

Remedies and Personal Liability

Because Cosare was constructively and illegally dismissed, the Court affirmed the NLRC’s monetary award. An illegally or constructively dismissed employee is generally entitled to reinstatement if viable, or separation pay if reinstatement is no longer viable, plus backwages. The Court also sustained exemplary damages because the NLRC found that the employer acted in bad faith and in a wanton, oppressive, and malevolent manner.

Significantly, Arevalo was held solidarily liable for the monetary awards because of the finding of bad faith. This is a warning to company presidents, owners, and senior officers: personal liability may arise when the dismissal is not merely erroneous but attended by bad faith or oppressive conduct. Corporate personality does not shield decision-makers who personally participate in unlawful termination carried out in bad faith.

Practical Lessons for Employers, Executives, and Employees

For employers, job titles should be treated carefully. Calling someone an assistant vice president, director, or officer does not automatically remove that person from labor-law protection. If a company intends a position to be a true corporate office, the position must be properly reflected in the by-laws and filled through the legally required corporate act. Even then, the nature of the dispute will still matter.

For HR managers, the case is a reminder that disciplinary procedure is not a technicality. A notice to explain must give enough factual detail and reasonable time to answer. Denying access, refusing explanations, imposing premature restrictions, or demanding resignation may transform a disciplinary process into evidence of constructive dismissal.

For employees and executives, the ruling provides a roadmap for forum selection. A dismissed employee who also owns shares or holds an executive title should not assume that the case belongs in a commercial court. If the core issue is termination of employment and the position is not a true corporate office, the Labor Arbiter remains the proper forum.

How Ablola, Saribong & Gueco Can Help

Ablola, Saribong & Gueco advises employers, executives, shareholders, and employees in disputes involving illegal dismissal, constructive dismissal, corporate officer status, intra-corporate controversy, NLRC proceedings, and executive termination strategy. If your case involves a disputed officer title, a forced resignation, a lockout, or uncertainty over whether to file before the Labor Arbiter or the commercial court, our litigation and labor law team can help assess jurisdiction, remedies, risks, and strategy. Visit MakatiLawFirm.com to consult our lawyers in Makati City.


Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *