Corporate officers named in by-laws cannot pursue removal disputes as ordinary NLRC illegal dismissal cases; the proper forum is the regular court.

Corporate presidents and other officers named in a corporation’s by-laws cannot automatically treat their removal as an ordinary illegal dismissal case before the NLRC. If the dispute concerns the election, appointment, term, or removal of a corporate officer, the case belongs to the regular courts as an intra-corporate controversy, and any labor judgment issued without jurisdiction may be void.

Why This Ruling Matters to Companies and Executives

The decision is important for corporations, schools, non-stock entities, foundations, and senior executives because it draws a hard jurisdictional line between ordinary employment disputes and corporate governance disputes. A person may receive a salary, benefits, an identification card, retirement benefits, and administrative support, yet still be treated in law as a corporate officer rather than a rank-and-file or managerial employee for purposes of forum and remedy.

For business owners and boards of trustees, the ruling confirms that the label used in payroll documents is not controlling. What matters is whether the office is created by the corporation’s charter or by-laws and whether the person was chosen through corporate action. For presidents, trustees, general managers, and similar officers, this means that the remedy for removal may not be an illegal dismissal complaint before the labor tribunals, but an intra-corporate case before the Regional Trial Court exercising special commercial jurisdiction.

Background of the Dispute

Wesleyan University-Philippines is a non-stock, non-profit, non-sectarian educational corporation. Atty. Guillermo T. Maglaya, Sr. became a corporate member in 2004, was elected as a member of the Board of Trustees, and was later elected President of the University for a five-year term. Disputes later arose over the expiration of the terms of certain corporate members and trustees, the appointment of new members and trustees, and the turnover of university administration.

After the new board and officers were introduced, Maglaya was informed that his services and authority as university president had been terminated. He first participated in an intra-corporate suit questioning the changes in the university’s corporate membership and governance. After that case was dismissed, he filed an illegal dismissal complaint before the labor tribunals against Wesleyan University-Philippines and certain bishops and officers. The Supreme Court resolved the case in Wesleyan University-Philippines v. Maglaya (G.R. No. 212774, January 23, 2017).

The NLRC Award and the Jurisdictional Problem

The Labor Arbiter initially dismissed the complaint for lack of jurisdiction, holding that Maglaya was a corporate officer and that the controversy was intra-corporate in nature. The NLRC reversed. It treated him as an employee, found that he had been illegally dismissed, and awarded separation pay, backwages, retirement pay, moral damages, exemplary damages, and attorney’s fees totaling P2,505,208.75.

The Court of Appeals later dismissed Wesleyan’s petition for certiorari on the theory that the NLRC decision had already become final and executory. The Supreme Court disagreed. It held that even if an NLRC decision becomes final after the ten-day period under the Labor Code, a party is not barred from filing a Rule 65 petition for certiorari before the Court of Appeals on jurisdictional and due process grounds, provided the petition is filed within the proper reglementary period.

The Corporate Officer Doctrine

The Court identified the central question as whether Maglaya was a corporate officer or a mere employee. It explained that corporate officers are those given that character by law, the corporation’s charter, or the corporation’s by-laws. The required corporate officers include the president, secretary, and treasurer, but the by-laws may create other offices. The Court distinguished an office from ordinary employment: an office is created by the charter or by-laws and filled by the directors or stockholders, while an employee generally occupies no corporate office and is hired by a managing officer who also determines compensation.

Applying that doctrine, the Court found that the President of Wesleyan University-Philippines was specifically mentioned in the university’s by-laws and was treated as part of the corporate structure. The by-laws made the president an honorary member of the Board and assigned functions involving university administration, reports to the Board, checks, discipline, and institutional management. The Court therefore held that Maglaya was not a mere employee for purposes of the dispute over his removal.

Salary and Benefits Do Not Convert a Corporate Officer into an Employee

One of the most practical points in the ruling is that compensation evidence did not control the forum. Maglaya relied on his appointment papers, identification card, policy manual, salary, allowances, retirement benefits, and check disbursements to argue that he was an employee. The Supreme Court rejected that approach. These facts may show that he was paid and given benefits, but they did not change the legal nature of the office created by the by-laws.

The Court also ruled that the use of the word appointment instead of election did not convert the university president into a mere employee. Since the office itself was identified in the by-laws and was filled by corporate action, the dispute remained corporate in character.

Removal of a Corporate Officer Is an Intra-Corporate Controversy

The Supreme Court reiterated that a corporate officer’s dismissal is a corporate act. The controversy does not become a simple labor problem merely because the removed officer claims unpaid wages, benefits, damages, or illegal dismissal. The reason or wisdom behind the board’s action does not alter the nature of the dispute. Where the controversy involves the rights of a corporate officer and the liability of the corporation arising from removal, the case falls within the jurisdiction of the regular courts, not the NLRC.

This matters in practice because filing in the wrong forum can completely defeat an otherwise serious claim. If a tribunal has no jurisdiction, its ruling cannot create rights or obligations. The Court held that a judgment void for lack of jurisdiction is no judgment at all; it cannot become final in the legal sense, and a writ of execution based on it is likewise void.

The Final Outcome

The Supreme Court granted Wesleyan University-Philippines’ petition, reversed the Court of Appeals, and affirmed the Labor Arbiter’s dismissal of the illegal dismissal complaint for lack of jurisdiction. Because the NLRC had no jurisdiction over the case, the monetary award could not stand. The Court ordered Maglaya to reimburse Wesleyan University-Philippines the P2,505,208.75 awarded by the NLRC.

Practical Lessons for Employers, Boards, and Senior Officers

For corporations and non-stock entities, the ruling underscores the importance of carefully drafting by-laws and board resolutions. If the by-laws create a particular corporate office, disputes over the appointment, term, or removal of the person holding that office will likely be treated as intra-corporate disputes. This affects not only litigation strategy but also risk assessment, forum selection, and settlement posture.

For executives, university presidents, trustees, general managers, and officers named in corporate by-laws, the ruling is a warning that an NLRC complaint may not be the proper remedy. Before filing, the officer must determine whether the claim arises from an ordinary employer-employee relationship or from corporate status. The wrong forum can result in dismissal and, as this case shows, even the loss of an already-issued monetary award.

For HR and legal departments, the case also shows that executive compensation packages, benefits, and employment-style documents should be aligned with the corporation’s governance documents. Confusion between employment documents and corporate appointment documents can create costly jurisdictional disputes.

How Ablola, Saribong & Gueco Can Help

Ablola, Saribong & Gueco assists corporations, schools, non-stock organizations, business owners, and executives in disputes involving corporate officers, board actions, intra-corporate controversies, and labor claims filed in the wrong forum. If your company is facing an NLRC case involving a president, trustee, director, general manager, or by-law officer, or if you are an executive removed from office and need to identify the proper remedy, our litigation team can help assess jurisdiction, strategy, evidence, and available relief. Visit MakatiLawFirm.com to consult with our lawyers.


Leave a Comment

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *