Corporate Officers Cannot Convert Boardroom Removal Disputes Into Labor Cases

Corporate officers removed over acts tied to their office must sue in the proper court, not before the Labor Arbiter, when the dispute is intra-corporate. Corporate officers who are removed because of acts tied to their official corporate functions cannot automatically sue before the Labor Arbiter for illegal dismissal. When the disputed removal is rooted […]

Condo Owners Can Void Board Elections Held Without the Right Quorum

The Supreme Court voided a condominium corporation election for lack of quorum, clarifying member attendance, developer rights, and proxy limits. Condominium corporations cannot validate a board election by counting voting weight as if it were the same as member attendance. For unit owners, the practical rule is powerful: when a non-stock condominium corporation holds a […]

When a President Is a Corporate Officer, the NLRC Cannot Award Illegal Dismissal Damages

Corporate officers named in by-laws cannot pursue removal disputes as ordinary NLRC illegal dismissal cases; the proper forum is the regular court. Corporate presidents and other officers named in a corporation’s by-laws cannot automatically treat their removal as an ordinary illegal dismissal case before the NLRC. If the dispute concerns the election, appointment, term, or […]

When Corporate Disputes Belong in the RTC, Not the Sandiganbayan

PCGG involvement does not automatically place a corporate dispute in Sandiganbayan; intra-corporate controversies belong before designated RTC courts. A corporation challenging a government-held shareholder interest cannot automatically go to the Sandiganbayan simply because the Presidential Commission on Good Government is involved. When the dispute concerns shareholder rights, board conflicts, capital stock, or stock exchange listing […]

Punitive Damages in Corporate Disputes Cannot Be Collected While the Appeal Is Still Pending

The Court ruled that exemplary damages and attorney’s fees in intra-corporate cases cannot be immediately executed while appeal remains pending. Parties who win an intra-corporate case cannot immediately collect exemplary damages or attorney’s fees while the losing side’s appeal remains pending. Even when corporate dispute decisions are generally immediately executory, punitive and discretionary monetary awards […]

Calling an Employee a Corporate Officer Will Not Remove Labor Court Jurisdiction

The Court held that job titles alone do not make an employee a corporate officer, and loss of confidence requires proof plus due process. Companies cannot defeat an illegal dismissal case simply by calling a dismissed employee a corporate officer. Unless the position is created by the corporation’s charter or by-laws, and unless the employer […]

Corporate Officers Cannot Convert Boardroom Removal Disputes Into Labor Cases

Corporate officers removed from by-law-created positions must pursue intra-corporate remedies, not ordinary NLRC illegal dismissal claims for reinstatement and backwages. Corporate officers who are removed from positions created by a corporation’s by-laws cannot automatically treat the dispute as an ordinary illegal dismissal case. When the controversy concerns the election, appointment, or removal of a corporate […]

Corporate Officers Cannot Turn Board Removal Into an Ordinary Illegal Dismissal Case

Corporate officer removal by board action may be an intra-corporate controversy, not an NLRC illegal dismissal case. Forum choice can decide the dispute. A corporate officer removed by board action may not automatically sue before the labor tribunal for illegal dismissal, because the dispute may be an intra-corporate controversy rather than an ordinary employer-employee case. […]

Corporate Control Disputes Belong Before the Corporate Regulator, Not the Trial Court

Corporate control disputes cannot be disguised as ordinary rescission suits; jurisdiction follows the substance of the shareholder and management controversy. A lawsuit framed as rescission, damages, or injunction may still be an intra-corporate controversy when its real object is to recover control, management, board seats, or shareholder power in a corporation. For shareholders, banks, investors, […]