RMO No. 12-2019 clarifies approval, appeal, and implementation rules for BIR administrative case decisions involving long suspensions and dismissals.
BIR regional offices must now follow a stricter approval route when administrative cases involving light offenses result in suspension beyond 30 days or dismissal from the revenue service. RMO No. 12-2019 matters because a decision signed at the regional level may not be enough where the penalty is serious: suspension exceeding 30 days requires approval by the Commissioner of Internal Revenue, while dismissal requires both approval by the Commissioner and confirmation by the Secretary of Finance.
What RMO No. 12-2019 Changed
RMO No. 12-2019 prescribes the policies, guidelines, and procedures for decisions on administrative cases signed and approved by the Regional Director under Revenue Administrative Order No. 4-2017. It clarifies how administrative case decisions involving BIR personnel should be prepared, approved, transmitted, and implemented when the penalty goes beyond a simple reprimand or short suspension.
The most important clarification is the division of authority. Regional Directors may review, approve, and sign decisions in certain administrative cases involving light offenses. However, where the penalty is suspension for more than thirty days, the decision must be approved and signed by the Commissioner of Internal Revenue. Where the imposable penalty is dismissal from the revenue service, the decision must be approved and signed by the Commissioner of Internal Revenue and confirmed by the Secretary of Finance before implementation.
This is particularly relevant for searches such as BIR administrative cases, RMO No. 12-2019 administrative penalties, BIR employee dismissal procedure, Regional Director administrative case decision, and BIR suspension more than 30 days. The issuance is not about taxpayer filing deadlines or tax rates, but it directly affects the integrity, enforceability, and finality of BIR personnel disciplinary decisions.
Who Is Affected by RMO No. 12-2019
The immediate affected parties are BIR revenue officials and employees involved in administrative cases, especially cases for light offenses under the Revised Rules on Administrative Cases in the Civil Service, the 2017 Rules on Administrative Cases in the Civil Service, and the Revised Code of Conduct for BIR Officials and Employees under RMO No. 53-2010.
The issuance also affects Regional Directors, Assistant Regional Directors, Legal Divisions, the Internal Affairs Service, the Personnel Adjudication Division, the Department of Finance, and offices responsible for custody of records, employee accountabilities, and system access. For businesses and taxpayers, the relevance is indirect but important: RMO No. 12-2019 helps define who within the BIR may validly act on internal disciplinary decisions, which affects institutional accountability and internal governance.
Taxpayers, corporate accountants, and in-house counsel may encounter this issuance when dealing with questions about BIR personnel accountability, administrative discipline, validity of BIR regional decisions, or internal complaints involving revenue officials or employees.
Penalties Covered by the Order
RMO No. 12-2019 applies to decisions signed by Regional Directors in administrative cases for light offenses under Section 46(F), Rule 10 of the Revised Rules on Administrative Cases in the Civil Service, Section 50(F), Rule 10 of the 2017 Rules on Administrative Cases in the Civil Service, and Section 43 of the Revised Code of Conduct for BIR Officials and Employees.
For light offenses under the civil service rules, the penalties are reprimand for the first offense, suspension of one day to thirty days for the second offense, and dismissal from the service for the third offense. The same penalty structure applies to light offenses under the Revised Code of Conduct for Revenue Officials and Employees, except for Simple Dishonesty.
Simple Dishonesty has a separate penalty structure. For the first offense, the penalty is suspension of one month and one day to six months. For the second offense, the penalty is suspension of six months and one day to one year. For the third offense, the penalty is dismissal from the service.
Key Approval Rules for Regional Director Decisions
The Legal Division is responsible for drafting decisions on administrative cases involving light offenses as defined under the RRACCS, the 2017 RACCS, and the Revised Code of Conduct for BIR Officials and Employees. The Regional Director’s authority depends on the offense and the resulting penalty.
If the respondent is found guilty for the first time of any light offense, except Simple Dishonesty, or for the second time of the same light offense, the Regional Director reviews, approves, and signs the decision.
If the respondent is found guilty for the first or second time of Simple Dishonesty, the Regional Director reviews and signs the decision but must recommend its approval to the Commissioner of Internal Revenue. This is because the penalties for Simple Dishonesty exceed the ordinary penalty range for typical light offenses.
If the respondent is found guilty for the third time of the same light offense, or for the third time of Simple Dishonesty, the Regional Director reviews and signs the decision and recommends approval by the Commissioner of Internal Revenue and confirmation by the Secretary of Finance. This reflects the fact that the third offense results in dismissal from the revenue service.
Finality, Appeal, and Execution of Decisions
RMO No. 12-2019 also clarifies when decisions become final and executory. A decision imposing reprimand or suspension for not more than thirty days is not appealable. This means the disciplinary consequence is treated as final at that level, subject to the governing civil service rules cited in the issuance.
If the penalty imposed is suspension exceeding thirty days, the decision becomes final and executory after the lapse of the reglementary period for filing a motion for reconsideration or appeal, provided no such pleading has been filed. If a motion for reconsideration is filed within the reglementary period, execution of the decision is stayed.
For appeals, the rule is different. Even if an appeal is pending, the decision is executory, except where the penalty is removal from office. If the penalty is removal or dismissal from the revenue service, execution takes place only after confirmation by the Secretary of Finance.
Required Transmittal and Confidentiality Procedures
Where the decision signed by the Regional Director requires action by the National Office, the entire case docket must be indorsed and transmitted to the Office of the Commissioner through the Internal Affairs Service. This applies particularly where the penalty is dismissal and therefore requires Commissioner approval and Department of Finance confirmation.
The transmittal of an administrative case docket must always include a Confidential Top Sheet as required under RMO No. 12-2014, which implements the Information Asset Classification Guidelines. This requirement is important because administrative case records may contain sensitive personnel information, evidence, and disciplinary findings.
Implementation After Commissioner Approval
Decisions signed and approved by the Commissioner of Internal Revenue are implemented by the Personnel Adjudication Division following existing revenue issuances. Where confirmation by the Department of Finance is required, the transmittal of approved BIR decisions to the Department of Finance is also undertaken by the Personnel Adjudication Division.
RMO No. 12-2019 adopts the policies under RMO No. 1-2011 on implementation of decisions by the Personnel Adjudication Division, turnover of property accountabilities, responsibilities of the head of office of the dismissed employee, obligations of the dismissed employee, and responsibilities of the Security Management Division regarding system access.
For dismissals, this means the process does not end with the signing of a decision. There must be proper implementation, accounting for government property, handling of office responsibilities, and control over system access. These are practical safeguards designed to prevent unauthorized access, unresolved property accountability, or premature execution of a dismissal decision.
Effective Date and Immediate Compliance
RMO No. 12-2019 took effect immediately on March 1, 2019. Regional offices, Legal Divisions, and personnel units handling administrative cases were therefore required to apply these procedures upon effectivity.
The immediate compliance point is straightforward: before implementing an administrative decision involving suspension exceeding thirty days or dismissal from the revenue service, the approving office must verify whether the Regional Director may approve the decision alone or whether Commissioner approval and Department of Finance confirmation are required.
Practical Steps for BIR Administrative Case Compliance
For BIR offices and counsel handling administrative matters, the first step is to identify the exact offense and determine whether it is a light offense under the applicable civil service rules or the Revised Code of Conduct for BIR Officials and Employees. The next step is to determine whether the offense is Simple Dishonesty, because Simple Dishonesty carries longer suspension periods even for the first and second offenses.
After identifying the offense and offense count, the approving authority must be checked. Reprimand and suspension not exceeding thirty days may fall within the Regional Director’s authority. Suspension beyond thirty days requires the Commissioner of Internal Revenue. Dismissal requires approval by the Commissioner of Internal Revenue and confirmation by the Secretary of Finance.
The case docket should then be prepared for proper routing. If the case must go to the National Office, the Regional Director-signed decision and the entire docket must be indorsed to the Office of the Commissioner through the Internal Affairs Service. The transmittal must include the required Confidential Top Sheet under RMO No. 12-2014.
Finally, implementation should be coordinated with the Personnel Adjudication Division. For dismissal cases, implementation should also consider turnover of property accountabilities, the obligations of the dismissed employee, the role of the employee’s head of office, and system access controls handled by the Security Management Division.
Why This Matters for Governance and Tax Administration
RMO No. 12-2019 is an internal administrative issuance, but it has broader significance for tax administration. The BIR’s credibility depends not only on tax assessments, audits, and enforcement actions, but also on clear internal accountability rules. By clarifying who may approve suspensions exceeding thirty days and dismissals, the issuance reduces the risk of premature, unauthorized, or procedurally defective administrative action.
For businesses dealing with the BIR, the issuance is a reminder that administrative authority within the Bureau is structured and document-driven. Whether the concern involves personnel accountability, internal discipline, or the validity of official action, the applicable revenue issuances must be checked carefully.
How Ablola, Saribong & Gueco Can Help
Ablola, Saribong & Gueco advises businesses, corporate officers, accountants, and regulated entities on BIR compliance, tax controversy, administrative procedure, and government-facing legal strategy. Our Makati-based team helps clients understand revenue issuances, respond to BIR actions, prepare compliance documents, and manage tax and regulatory risks before they become costly disputes.
If your company needs guidance on BIR compliance, administrative proceedings, tax assessments, internal investigations, or government regulatory requirements, consult Ablola, Saribong & Gueco through MakatiLawFirm.com.